Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Here comes the budget

Update : 03 Jun 2015, 07:44 PM

The budget numbers are almost out. There is possibly no need for the finance minister to give a lengthy speech on the budget in parliament and end up feeling like he had the wind knocked out of him. A crisp power point presentation, along with a prefix highlighting the achievements and the vision of the ruling party is enough. The parties concerned can easily access the full text or the finance bill from the Internet or through their accounting or tax advisers.

Thanks to the very pro-active media in Bangladesh, we have a respectable visibility of the budget numbers. The total budget was thought to be around Tk290,000cr with an ADP size of Tk92,000cr. In order to accommodate the many last-minute wishes and demands, it is now rumoured to have become more than Tk300,000cr with an ADP of Tk97,000cr.

I am told that the last Tk5,000cr in ADP addition came from nobody other than the PM herself. So, the finance division was supposed to back-calculate the numbers to adjust with the new realities.

Our finance minister keeps on telling us that his wish is to make our budget outlay to be 25% of the country’s GDP. If our GDP is Tk1,400,000cr, the FY2016 budget is almost 21% of our GDP. Congrats to Mr finance minister! This is also his eighth budget for this republic.

The finance minister also wishes our tax/GDP ratio would go up from the present 11% to 14% of the GDP. I guess here is the shoe-pinching for him and for us all. The FY2014 budget wanted Tk136,000cr to be realised through NBR sources -- income tax, VAT, and customs duty.

Ultimately, the number had to be adjusted downward to Tk125,000cr. The outgoing fiscal estimated NBR earnings of Tk149,000cr. The estimate has already been adjusted downwards to Tk135,000cr income tax, down by more than Tk8,000cr; it’s the same with VAT, with customs duty realisation showing an upside of Tk2,000cr with increased imports.

While the NBR is showing a Tk140,000cr shortfall, analysts are saying it could be much higher. The upcoming budget is projecting NBR source revenue earnings of Tk170,000cr. With the present governance structure, capacity, and most importantly, the haphazard way the budget numbers have been managed, it is turning out to be a next-to-impossible challenge.

I am very much okay with the 5.14% budget deficit. I find comfort in the large foreign exchange reserve, the weak opposition, next to no political threats, and the heavy investment in infrastructure building. However, I am not okay with the huge revenue earnings target.

Despite a large increase in consumer spending and domestic market demand, we are not seeing a spike in our VAT collection, caused due to package rates or blanket arrangements or otherwise. With a tremendous rise in consumerism and the service industry, our VAT collection should at least be double of what it is, but here we are talking of more than $1bn downsizing.

Indonesia, Philippines, or even India had shown a spike in VAT earnings with the expansion of organised and unorganised retail. On the income tax front, we knew how rich one of our mayoral candidates was when he was asked to comment on low assets and tax payment.

As we increasingly get interfaced with global markets with expanding regional integration, we have to rationalise our tariff structure even further. In that case, I will be all-too surprised to see Bangladesh achieving its Tk211,000cr (including non-NBR sources) revenue target during FY2016s.

We are happy to see our budget allocation going up and up. We should not forget that we want ourselves to be in the league of “middle income countries.” In that case, our per capita income rise is not enough by itself. We need improvements in the standard of living as well as access to better education and health services.

With a large passenger population, we have to keep on allocating money for a social safety net too. Nor can we forget about the loss-making public enterprises, or dare rationalise our defense budget. Especially when our honourable PM wants us to start exporting arms.

Development partners seemed to be doing enough despite a weak governance and a lack of political harmony. Some of them are said to be reaching the point of saturation. Private investment is low for many known reasons.

What should we do then? Even a literature-student-turned-economic-commentator would say that we need to mobilise our internal resources. We have to increase our revenue earnings.

We have to keep on allowing the NGOs/MFIs to bring in further synergy in rural Bangladesh, encourage non-farm agriculture, and make further investments into urban private businesses. 

Top Brokers