Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Ready to serve

Update : 20 May 2015, 07:13 PM

Public policy champion Dr Akbar Ali Khan has written a fantastic book: Gresham’s Law Syndrome and Beyond. Thank God all his CSP friends are either retired or dead. Knowing many of them, those East India Company relics were not ready to accept any criticism. I don’t know how many of our new civil bureaucrats friends will, or even can, read Dr Khan’s book. If at all, they are likely to keep mum.

I had the opportunity of giving lectures in front of the mid-ranking and senior civil servants at Bangladesh public administration training centre (BPATC) for a few years. While I found many of them to be law-abiding citizens respectful to the chain of command, a few of them were very rowdy and kept their upper chambers shut from any learning.

I’d even heard from some of the faculty there that a few civil servants were found resorting to various “short-cuts” for passing internal exams. This may be reflective of the recent degradation of our society. We have even seen BCS examinees resorting to damaging public property on the streets. Even in our wildest dreams, we didn’t expect our would-be public servants, our “custodians of conscience,” to behave with disrespect towards the norms they are expected to uphold.

Maybe it is the reflection of a weak democracy or our “winner take all” mentality, or even the ruling party’s own perceived infallibility -- there is a growing impatience in our society and country. We are approaching a resolution which prescribes that “only street movements can help us achieve our targets, our legitimate claims.”

We don’t trust our governments, we can’t rely on the institutions which are supposed to safeguard the interest of the common man, or provide us with the right answer to a dispute or a question.

Much damage has been dealt to our civil service, and we are actively failing to attract further talents into our civil service. Even though we can attract many, they are increasingly losing their seats to the “below-average” people due to the “my man or their man” style campaigning seen recently.

Even if we take into cognisance the steps taken lately -- the increasing of the age limit, introduction of the senior secretary designation, elevation of the status of a few police jobs, and mass promotions to the posts of deputy secretary and joint secretary -- it becomes quite clear that those are the cunning designs of the ruling party established for passing the election, the popularity battle, at the cost of the public exchequer.

Go to the ministries or the secretariat and you will see firsthand how some of the joint secretaries or additional secretaries are behaving like the joint or additional secretaries of the ruling party.

I have recently witnessed an additional secretary at the Ministry of Education behaving more like a party loyalist than a public servant. I have seen a bigtime “policeman,” employed at the passport and immigration services department, addressing the honourable prime minister as “netri” or “leader” every now and then. He was telling us what she should be doing in handling the opposition.

Of course, civil servants are citizens themselves, and are likely to subscribe to one political school of thought or other. As long as they are voters, they are supposed to go to a polling centre and vote for a political party or candidate.

However, behaving like a “political worker,” trying to marginalise their colleagues sitting at the table next to them for belonging to a different school of thought, or even independent thoughts, is not right. Abusing power for personal gain is not acceptable either.

The entire world is changing. The private sector, in most emerging countries, are taking the “centre of the plate” position. Bangladesh cannot be so different. Civil bureaucracy should be seen as a catalyst for driving change in this country too.

Exceptions are always there. Everything is not gone either. While we can’t rely much on the judiciary or even the parliament or the Anti Corruption Commission, we can’t expect much from the civil bureaucracy either. Even within the civil bureaucracy, there are plenty of bright men and women. They are not being harnessed well, however, they are not being groomed well to bring in easy solutions to an issue only thought to be complex.

I still remember the additional secretary at the Home Ministry who solved a friend’s long-pending renunciation case within minutes. Hats-off to our few bureaucrat friends at the finance division, the energy division, and even the land ministry -- their knowledge base is perhaps second to none, even compared to their predecessors.

But again, exceptions, unfortunately, can’t be the rule. Let’s accept that we are failing to attract good people into our civil bureaucracy, and that we are failing to nourish them according to their core competence. If we really wish growth to be real, and for sustainable growth with distributive justice, then we must invest in our civil bureaucracy -- there’s no other way. 

Top Brokers