Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

ChatGPT in the legal field

Is there potential for the chat-based AI in the legal profession in Bangladesh?

Update : 07 Jun 2023, 12:50 AM

In recent years, there has been a significant rise in the use of chat-based AI, also known as conversational AI. Chat-based AI uses natural language processing (NLP) and machine learning algorithms to understand and respond to user queries and conversations in a human-like manner.

With the increasing popularity of messaging apps and the growth of online communication, it is anticipated that chat-based AI shall become even more prevalent in the future, offering new opportunities for businesses and organizations to engage with their audiences.

Such a chat-based AI, rather the most popular one at present, is ChatGPT; an artificial intelligence language model developed by OpenAI, which surprisingly holds innumerable potential of being used in the legal profession, amongst others, providing lawyers and law firms with natural language processing capabilities to improve efficiency and accuracy in their work.

The use of artificial intelligence (AI) in the legal profession is not new, rather it dates back to the early 2000s with the development of eDiscovery software like Relativity and Recommind to aid in document review. Since then, AI has been employed in legal research with apps like Ross Intelligence and LexisNexis, contract review using software like Kira Systems and LawGeex, and even predicting case outcomes with tools such as CaseCrunch and Blue J Legal.

The question, therefore, is: Can ChatGPT bring anything new to the table, so far as the legal profession is concerned?

One of the primary ways that ChatGPT may be used in the legal profession is through legal document analysis. Lawyers can upload legal documents, such as contracts, into the system and use ChatGPT to analyze and extract key information, such as clauses or key terms. This can significantly reduce the time and effort required for manual document review and analysis, allowing lawyers to invest their time on more sophisticated tasks.

ChatGPT may also be utilized to provide legal research assistance, with lawyers and law firms using the system to search for case laws or legislations relevant to their cases. This can provide to be extremely time-efficient and require fewer resources, compared to existing legal research methods.

It is, however, pertinent to note that while ChatGPT has access to most legislations in Bangladesh that are available in the public domain, case laws do not yet appear in the results. Hopefully in the near future, when Bangladeshi case laws are more widely digitalized and available in the public domain, ChatGPT is likely to streamline the search and analysis of case laws as well.

This presents myriad of opportunities for the legal profession as a whole; for instance, ChaptGPT may be able to produce an entire legal opinion on a given matter, including references to legislative provisions and relevant case laws.

Another potential usage of ChatGPT, or AI in a broader sense, in the legal profession may be through legal chatbots. In the legal profession, chatbots can be used to provide basic legal advice and assistance to clients, reducing the need for lawyers to handle routine inquiries.

One must, however, note that the use of chatbots for legal advice raises questions around the extent to which the advice provided is accurate and reliable, and whether it can be relied upon by clients. As such, it is important for lawyers and law firms planning to use ChatGPT to ensure that the system has been appropriately trained and tested, and that any potential errors or biases are identified and addressed.

Regarding the proficiency of Bengali language, given that numerous legislations are published in Bengali language, it appears that ChatGPT has taught itself to reply using Bengali, however the results are very slow and often filled with inconsistent words. Therefore, it is safe to say that ChatGPT has a long way to go before it can fluently identify legislations written in Bengali and provide accurate results.

In terms of assisting the judiciary, ChatGPT claims (when asked by the authors) that as an AI language model, it can assist judges in writing judgments by analyzing and summarizing the arguments presented in petitions filed by both parties. It claimed to identify relevant legal precedents, case law, and statutory provisions related to the issue at hand, and provide suggestions for language and formatting. Additionally, ChatGPT claimed (when asked by the authors) that it can help the judge evaluate the strengths and weaknesses of the arguments presented by both parties, and offer suggestions for how to address any inconsistencies or gaps in reasoning. This can help ensure that the judgment is well-reasoned, logical, and consistent with legal principles. 

It needs to be noted that there remain potential legal and ethical implications that need to be carefully considered. For example, the use of ChatGPT to analyze legal documents raises yet unanswered questions regarding the accuracy and reliability of the system's output, and whether it can be trusted to identify key terms and clauses accurately. Therefore, the results produced by ChatGPT must ultimately be supervized by a lawyer to ensure its accuracy.

There are also concerns around data privacy and ownership in the use of ChatGPT in the legal profession. Lawyers and law firms must ensure that any data collected by the system is protected and used in compliance with local data protection laws. There is also a question of who owns the data generated by the system, with some arguing that it should be owned by the clients who provide the data rather than the lawyers or law firms that use it.

The government of Bangladesh is yet to take steps to regulate the use of artificial intelligence (AI) and ensure that it is used in compliance with local laws and regulations. While the legal system of Bangladesh does not have any specific laws regulating the usage of AI, some existing laws may provide guidance as to how AI based systems should be used and operated:

1.    Digital Security Act 2018: The Act regulates digital activities in Bangladesh through provisions related to the misuse of digital devices, including computers, and criminalizes activities such as cyber-terrorism, hacking, and spreading of false information through digital media. 

2.    Data Protection Bill 2022: The Data Protection Bill 2022 is a proposed legislation in Bangladesh that aims to regulate the processing of personal data. The bill proposes organizations that collect and process personal data to obtain consent from data subjects, ensure the accuracy and security of the data, and notify data subjects in case of data breaches. 

3.    National Strategy for Artificial Intelligence Bangladesh 2019-2024: National Strategy for Artificial Intelligence Bangladesh 2019-2014 is a framework developed by the government of Bangladesh to guide the development of AI related activities in the country. The framework includes provisions related to the use of AI in various sectors, such as healthcare, agriculture, and education, to improve efficiency and effectiveness. The strategy further proposes the incorporation of strong legal and ethical framework on how AI will be implemented in different sectors.

There are obvious concerns with ChatGPT, it being a relatively new technology and far from being perfect; the use of ChatGPT in the legal profession in Bangladesh has the potential to revolutionize the way that lawyers and law firms work, improving efficiency, reducing costs, and providing access to legal services to those who may not have been able to access them before.

Nevertheless, the usage of ChatGPT does entail some potential dangers so far as the legal profession is concerned. For instance, users have no influence on the methods used to collect information, the data used, or the algorithm the system uses. This heavily depends on how the AI system was developed by OpenAI.

The creators of ChatGPT confirmed that the system can write plausible sounding but incorrect answers and admitted that fixing this issue is challenging. For instance, upon inquiring ChatGPT about the laws relating to payment of gratuity to workers in Bangladesh, it came up with the right content of the law but with wrong legal references that deal with maternity leave in the Labour Act 2006. Legal professionals must therefore exercise extreme caution while using ChatGPT for legal research.

In addition, all rights, titles, and interests in respect to the response are assigned to the user, according to OpenAI's terms and conditions. It is made clear that responses might not all be original and might be given more than once. Users might receive the same or extremely similar responses as a result of this. Regarding the enforcement of any copyright, this creates issues.

It is also vital to note that ChatGPT's comments are based on previously published works. If a user publishes a ChatGPT response that is similar to one already in existence, they potentially run the risk of unintentionally violating existing copyright.

In conclusion, to quote Professor Kristian Hammond of the Northwestern University (US) and director of the Center for Advancing Safety of Machine Intelligence: “You have to understand the length and breadth of the technology and where it collapses, and make sure the task is not one that demands something beyond its limits. ChatGPT might be good at taking a test. But, because of the nature of the underlying mechanism, it may never be capable of genuine reasoning, being imaginative, or thinking beyond the moment.”

The use of ChatGPT in the legal profession in Bangladesh, and all around the world, is a promising development that has the potential to provide significant benefits to lawyers, law firms, and clients alike. However, it can be generally agreed that the adoption of ChatGPT for full-fledged legal research shall be rather slow. Some general tasks such as due diligence of financial documents or vetting of contracts may be done, however, one must bear in mind that it is not yet a perfect technology, and there are potential legal and ethical implications that need to be carefully monitored.

In spite of the above, the use of ChatGPT can certainly act as an aiding tool and help improve efficiency, reduce costs, increase access to legal services and streamlining justice delivery.


Saqeb Mahbub is Partner, Mahbub & Company ([email protected]). Nafis Shahriar Khan is Associate, Mahbub & Company ([email protected]).

Top Brokers