Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Why change the impeachment law?

Update : 26 Aug 2014, 07:30 PM

The constitutional amendment bill approved by the Council of Ministers which will give the Jatiya Sangsad the power to impeach supreme court judges is the wrong way to go.

In the first place, it is unclear to us why there is any need to change the current system which allows for a Supreme Judicial Council to impeach judges. We have seen no evidence that the present system is not working, and the general consensus among legal practitioners is that it would be preferable to putting the impeachment power in the hands of legislators.

While there is nothing intrinsically wrong with allowing parliament this power, and it exists in other countries, given the reality of the political polarisation in Bangladesh, this is surely an unwise step.

The ultimate impact would be to make the judiciary subordinate to the parliament, which would invariably lead to judges not feeling free to exercise their consciences independently.

Many cases have a political dimension or implicate people who have links with parliamentarians. Even giving the appearance of parliamentary control over the courts could inhibit the judiciary from taking due action in such cases. The fact that the parliament is typically (as is the case right now) dominated by legislators of one party only makes the problem even more acute.

The biggest casualty of the constitutional amendment bill will ultimately be respect for the judiciary, as the judiciary would always in future be vulnerable to accusations of political pressure even if the impeachment power were to be exercised judiciously.

There is nothing wrong with the existing mechanism for impeaching judges, and thus there is no need to effect a fix that not only runs the risk of curtailing judicial independence but will also invariably diminish the public’s confidence in the judiciary, which is something no one wants.

Top Brokers