Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

BNP arrests undermine dialogue

Update : 09 Jan 2014, 06:05 PM

The nature and timing of the recent arrest of three senior BNP leaders as well as the denial of bail and remand pleas of six others gives us cause for disquiet.

There is a case to be made that calling hartals and blockades makes one complicit in the violence that ensues. There has been enough carnage over the past year during virtually every program of hartal and blockade that the link to violence is now quite hard to treat as coincidental.

However, the government may need to explicitly change the law before such strict measures against hartal and blockades can be enforced. And any such change must still be consistent with the basic rights enshrined in the constitution. It must indeed also safeguard freedoms essential for democratic politics.

Given existing laws and practice though, it is hard not to see the charges filed as anything but tendentious. The connection of the three arrested to the violence seems tenuous, at best.

Further, given the age and health of the persons involved, it would be reasonable in these cases to expect bail to be granted.

The fact that the arrests occurred after the accused spoke out on behalf of their party makes it seem as if the government is using these kinds of charges to silence the opposition, and the denial of bail and removal to remand supports this inference.

Similarly the rejection of bail and remand pleas of the six senior BNP leaders, five of whom have already been behind bars for two months, appears excessive and unnecessarily punitive.

At a time when constructive dialogue is still the public expectation, and possibly the best way to a durable solution, arresting and detaining key figures in this manner, in addition to others already held, does not strike us as helpful to creating a conducive climate for talks. The opposition too is not helping that climate by persisting with the most destructive forms of political protest.

The government must find a way to either start a new dialogue or apprehend real perpetrators of violence. But it must not be seen to be seeking to apply state power to weaken the opposition.

Top Brokers