The ban on cargo movements via the Sundarbans’ Shela river after Saturday’s sinking of the MV Sea Horse 1 vessel carrying over 1200 tonnes of coal, raises the question why it was not imposed before this accident.
It was already clear after the catastrophic oil spill in December 2014, when 358,000 litres of furnace oil spread into the mangrove forest, that the government needed to protect the Sundarbans waterways and quickly bring into operation safer alternative routes for hazardous shipments.
However, not only were past restrictions only maintained temporarily, and work on alternative routes repeatedly delayed, but authorities completely failed to learn lessons from a very similar capsize of a coal carrying boat just last October.
The unseemly haste shown by the shipping minister in reopening navigation on the Shela river after the big 2014 spill is indicative of a poor regard for both the environment and river safety.
It is long overdue for the government to hold the shipping minister to account for the poor state of safety on the nation’s rivers, not least because year after year this causes huge loss of life from capsizes that could and should have been prevented.
The steps needed to improve river safety are self-evident. The poor training and corruption which institutionalises poor boat maintenance and risky practices, such as overloading, has to end. There needs to be effective punishment for negligence and recklessness backed by proper enforcement of safety rules and stringent insurance requirements on vessel operators to incentivise them to improve standards and take more precautions.
None of this will happen if the government does not send a clear signal that the government will break from the past and hold ministers to account for failures.



