The annual ritual of the government proving it does what it shouldn’t be doing has just happened as the prices of Eid-ul-Azha hides was announced. This is the process by which the government announces the cost to the tanners of the skins of the animals sacrificed. Why the government shouldn’t be doing this being that we have no evidence at all that they know what the price of anything should be.
Most certainly not something both complex and trivial as the price of animal skins. Also not with something as obviously seasonal as this.
But even if government does know what the price should be, there’s still no point to them setting it - our basics of supply and demand do that for us already. There’s this concept of market clearing price that we have to deal with. This is the price at which every hide finds a home and everyone who wants a skin at that price gains one. We have, by definition, balanced supply and demand at this price.
So now imagine that the government sets that price. This violates Hayek’s insistence that the government - or any central economic actor - can ever have enough information to get this right but let’s ignore that for a moment.
If the price is set below that market clearing price, then there will be shortages. Which means a shortage at that lower price. Equally, if we set it above our perfect price then there will be surplus skins - some market participants will not want them at too high a price.
So, we can either have a dearth or surplus by fixing the price at anything other than the market clearing price. Or, of course, the government could be more efficient than Hayek thought is possible and somehow manage to set the price at exactly that correct one.
In which case, why bother?
We’ve reached, through the exercise of government power and effort, exactly the same answer we’d have reached by doing nothing and allowing everyone to go about their business undisturbed. That is, the government price fix will either be wrong or irrelevant.
So, why bother?
This becomes even more so in the case of something in seasonal glut. This is where we positively desire to have private speculators. Yes, people who make money simply by buying in that time of plenty and then selling at higher prices when there’s more of a shortage. It was Adam Smith who pointed out that what these financiers - profiteers if you like - are really doing is moving prices through time.
His example was wheat from harvest to harvest, but this seasonal glut of animal skins works exactly the same way. There is that peak of slaughter, meaning that there are many more skins available at one particular time than over the rest of the year, as a result of the more normal eating habits. In the absence of fixed - and wrong - prices that will mean a fall in prices just after Eid-ul-Azha. And then higher prices across the rest of the year. Some will - seeing easy money to be made - buy up stock at those low prices to sell at more normal, higher ones later.
Sure, raw hides don’t keep all that well, it’s necessary to process them at least a little bit so they don’t rot. But we know how to do that, it’s all part of the tanning process itself. But look at the effect those speculators have upon prices.
They become effective demand at that time of surplus. That means that prices are higher than they would be in their absence. This is good we assume - it means people trying to sell them are gaining a better price. Now they store and sell later. This means that prices are lower later on, when they do sell them.
Lower than they would be without their profit-making speculation that is. For they have moved some of those hides from the low-priced time immediately after the festival to the higher-priced later parts of the year. And they’ve moved the prices with them, they’ve saved some of the glut to be supplied at the time of dearth.
It’s the very presence of speculators that smoothens out those seasonal swings in prices. The lows are higher and the peaks lower. Even better, these speculators only make a profit if they get it right. If they buy too many then they’ll not be able to make a profit as they’ll not be able to sell them later in the year. If they don’t buy enough then they’re not actually speculating enough. Profit comes only from doing what we’d actually rather like to have done - move those prices through the seasons.
So, government price-fixing is unlikely to lead to the correct price and if it does there’s no point to it as the pure free market would reach that correct price if just left alone. The influence of speculators and hoarders is to move prices across time, exactly what we’d like to happen with something subject to seasonal gluts and shortages. So, don’t have the price fixing at all, why not use the government’s efforts towards something that actually needs doing. Possibly, even something that makes us all better off as well?
The market itself has already got this pricing business organised. The government should concern itself with only those things that markets don’t organise perfectly. And yes, there’s a lot of this world where that is true, plenty for them to be getting on with without doing what they shouldn’t be doing or don’t need to.
Tim Worstall is a senior fellow at the Adam Smith Institute in London.



