Metalsgrove Mining (ASX: MGA) shares are up 36% today. MGA shares rose on the report of the first drilling results from the Arunta project. They’ve good - good by conventional standards that is. There are rare earths there, there’s a decent ratio of magnet metals to others and it’s the magnet metals that everyone wants these days. There’s yttrium, which is saleable on its own. Well, they’re just fine as exploratory results in fact.
It is possible to carp just a little bit. For while the concentrations seem fair enough there is, as Metalsgrove itself points out, this to consider as well: “The grades returned in the Bruce drilling compare very favourably and indicate potential for the project if sufficient tonnes can be found.” They’re absolutely right about their reported results so far: “The HREO/TREO, MREO/TREO and NrPr/TREO ratios are all reasonable and comparable to other REE projects” and that is, as we say, entirely true. But that’s not enough of course. There also has to be enough of that rick there to make mining a worthwhile endeavour. There are overheads to mining anything, anywhere, so any deposit has to be large enough to cover those. That’s the thing which is unknown as yet.

We have a slightly different worry here. Which is that we’re not sure that the market is really concentrating upon how small the global rare earths business is. Yes, of course, it’s expanding. We’d all like to have regular supplies from outside China. More EVs and more electric motors means more magnets required. And yet even so it’s entirely possible for the market to go into oversupply. As it is right now: “The average Chinese domestic price of NdPr slid from $US86.60 ($129.70) a kilogram in the March quarter to $US60.30 a kilogram in the June quarter, and down from $US120.40 a kilogram in the same period last year.” One of the things is that the Nd/Pr price really has to stay about $40 for it to be worth mining the stuff. And certainly we think that people would find it very hard to finance a new mine at prices like that or lower.
Hard rock mining - these carbonatites are that - for rare earths could in fact be priced out of the market by the inherently cheaper ionic clays as at OD6 and Heavy Rare Earths. Note that we don’t say will be, only could be. But it’s possible that the in the ground value of even a rich hard rock rare earths deposit could approach zero in future.



