Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

BSF again justifies shootings as self-defence

Update : 29 Dec 2014, 08:32 PM

Indian Border Security Force chief Devendra Kumar Pathak yesterday echoed his predecessor to claim that his men open fire for self defence and that border killing incidents had decreased.

Since the BSF had started using non-lethal weapons to tackle trespassing, Pathak claimed that the incidents of attacks on their members increased alarmingly.

“The efforts to bring down the killings to zero level have been done at the very cost of BSF personnel’s lives,” he said during a joint briefing on the concluding day of 40th DG-level talks of Bangladesh and Indian border forces in the capital’s Pilkhana headquarters.

Pathak said the BSF did not differentiate between Bangladeshi or Indian nationals during self-defence.

“On Indian land, the Bangladeshi attackers as well as Indian nationals have been shot. And more importantly, deaths are taking place in the Indian territory and at midnight. This is the time, that criminals generally dare to cross the border and sneak into the other country’s border with ill motives.” 

However, asked whether all the BSF members use non-lethal weapons, Pathak said in 2010 a general policy was taken to adopt non-lethal weapons.

After last year’s conference, the then BSF director general Shubhash Joshi claimed that their men open fire for self defence as “according to the Indian law, every citizen has the right to self defence.”

He also said the BSF had been working to bring down the deaths to zero-level. “It’s a joint responsibility. The number of killings and incidents of injury along the border is reducing gradually,” Joshi said, adding that the BSF investigated each incident.

Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina last week said the Border Guard Bangladesh (BGB) had played a key role in decreasing the number of border killings in recent times.

Pathak yesterday said: “When the BSF members are certain that the intruders are going to commit crimes or that the force will be attacked, the first priority is self-defence...”

He said the number of deaths along border would have been higher had the BSF used lethal weapons.

Bangladesh shares 3,909 kilometre border with India.

In the latest incident of border killing farmer Moshiur Rahman Moshi was shot dead by the BSF on Thursday along the Medinipur frontier in the Jibonnagar upazila in Chuadanga.

The BSF delegation was in Dhaka at that time for the conference.

According to media reports, BSF members from the Putkhali border camp entered the Bangladesh territory and opened fire on a group of farmers, numbering four or five, while they were working in the fields around 5pm, leaving Moshi dead on the spot and two others injured.

However, the visiting BSF chief at the joint briefing said since 2010, number of deaths had decreased. “In 2007 it was 106, but in 2010 it was reduced to 32 , bring the numbers down further to 11 in the next two years.

“Figures can be increased here, decreased there. But look at the trend.”

He claimed that incidents of attack on the BSF members equipped with “non-lethal weapons” had increased. “In 2009, it was only 20, but in 2012 it increased to 151 and the following year to 122. The number is 99 until November this year,” the BSF DG claimed.

Indicating that Bangladesh needed to cooperate more, Pathak said: “[When] one side is using non-lethal weapons and are being attacked by unsocial elements and trans-border criminals, the other side needs to respond more.

“Any border force of the world is mandated to keep sanctity of the border. This is what the BGB is doing and this is what we are doing,” he said.

Asked if there was any proof that the Bangladeshi nationals had swooped on the BSF members with lethal weapons that provoked them to open fire, the BSF chief said: “Since the attackers could not be caught, we could not seize their arms. But medical reports of the injured jawans showed that lethal weapons were used.”

Talking to reporters, BGB chief Maj Gen Aziz Ahmed said the issue of deaths along border had been discussed for years at different levels of the two next-door neighbours. “But the incidents could not be brought down to zero level. So, at every DG-level meeting, it remains our top agenda of discussion.”

He said the two forces had identified some points along the border where incidents of killing and trespassing had increasing. “We will arrange joint patrol there while the list of identified points will be updated every six months.”

The two forces also agreed on taking measures like increasing vigilance in the areas “vulnerable” to cattle smuggling.

Regarding the retrial of the killing of Bangladeshi teenager Felani Khatun, the BSF chief said: “We do not want to announce any time frame because we do not have any control over the [special] court...The trial will take its own time. 

“During the first trial [when the lone accused was acquitted], certain aspects were overlooked while others not examined. So the case was sent back to the trial court...as of now, the case is under retrial.”

The BSF members shot dead Felani on January 7, 2011 while she was crossing the border into Bangladesh over barbed-wire fences at Anantapur of Phulbari in Kurigram. The retrial was adjourned for four months on November 20 as the accused had fallen ill.

Pathak refrained from commenting when asked about the Bardhaman blast of October 2 in which involvement of militants of banned Jama’atul Mujahideen Bangladesh have been found. “It’s under investigation,” he said.

At the conference, the BGB requested its counterpart to allow the use of existing border roads in India to facilitate construction and maintenance of new border outposts in remote areas of the Chittagong Hill Tracts until the allied facilities are acquired by the BGB. 

In response, the BSF requested for a detailed proposal, the BGB chief said.

Both the forces explored an idea of providing medical support to the BGB personnel deployed in remote areas in BSF’s medical establishments.

The BGB chief was leading a 23-member team while Pathak led a 19-member team to attend the six-day conference. The meeting emphasised on ways to control border crimes especially smuggling of arms and drugs in line with the Coordinated Border Management Plan signed on July 30, 2011. 

Top Brokers