Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

'Defence deal would require political consensus in Bangladesh and India'

Update : 18 Mar 2017, 02:14 AM

We have heard that a defence deal of some kind is likely to be signed between Bangladesh and India. What might it contain?

I have heard from various sources and read in media that some sort of undertaking is in the offing. Whether it is a defence agreement, a Memorandum of Understanding, or whatever form it takes, it will likely include a defence platform for the two countries to institutionalise cooperation. If that happened, it would be the first time Bangladesh agreed to an institutionalised platform for defence cooperation with India.

What would the two states cooperate about?

They might explore the possibility of joint ventures in defence and defence technology, and joint efforts at capacity-building with regard to armaments and training, and maybe maritime infrastructure building too.
Also Read- Between a rock and a hard place

Could a deal like this make Bangladesh a loser in the long run?

To be viable, any sort of defence deal would require a political consensus in both countries. Since we have a political regime that is not functioning properly, there would at least have to be a public consultation. The honourable prime minister enjoys a very strong position and has good reason to be confident. I am quite sure she will be sensitive to public perception. Why do we need to rush? I do not believe this is the right time for Bangladesh for such a deal.Members of the Indian Army, Strike 1 participate in a mock drill exercise, 'Megh Prahar' on the banks of the Yamuna River in Mathura on July 14, 2016. Excercise 'Megh Prahar' demonstrated the capabilities of Mathura-based Strike 1 to effect crossings of a river obstacle and tested the effectiveness of the Ultra Modern Tank T-90 and BMP-2 in crossing a river AFP Members of the Indian Army, Strike 1 participate in a mock drill exercise, 'Megh Prahar' on the banks of the Yamuna River in Mathura on July 14, 2016. Excercise 'Megh Prahar' demonstrated the capabilities of Mathura-based Strike 1 to effect crossings of a river obstacle and tested the effectiveness of the Ultra Modern Tank T-90 and BMP-2 in crossing a river AFP

Why not?

One reason is that we are in the midst of our own defence modernisation effort – and the goal is 2030. Until we have implemented it, undertakings of this kind are unnecessary. Let's be very clear about one very important thing: Bangladesh is not a security or defence recipient. Bangladesh is a defence provider. Bangladesh has substantially provided security to India, in addition to extensive support to UN peace-keeping missions. We have played a key role in underwriting stability and security in India's north-eastern region. Secondly, there is currently a difference between Bangladesh's and India's weaponry and equipment. When Bangladesh's capacity grows, we can think about a deal. We neither have the political nor strategic necessity for such a deal. Bangladeshi-Indian cooperation on law enforcement capacity building will be more useful than a defence agreement or MoU.
Also Read- Bangladesh, India to hold joint military exercise from Nov 5

So why is a possible deal even an issue?

More because of India's interest in it. The deepening of Sino-Bangladesh relations could be a cause of concern for India. India sees this growing relationship through the lens of its strategic needs. Bangladesh’s relations with China, and indeed the world, are not strategic but economic. Seen through the lens of our national objectives as a successful trading state, Bangladesh should not sign defence-related undertakings with any country at the moment.

So Bangladesh's growing trade with China is causing India to pursue a defence deal with us?

It would apparently seem so. It was just after our economic deals with China that India began seriously pushing the defence issue. [arve url="https://www.facebook.com/plugins/video.php?href=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.facebook.com%2FIndianarmy.adgpi%2Fvideos%2F569383529924947%2F&show_text=1&width=560" title="Combat training activities during joint military training exercise between Indian and Bangladesh armies during Exercise Sampriti 2016"/] We all know that India has been setting up a barbed-wire fence on the Bangladesh-India border. And we know that India has been helping Myanmar build its defence capacity. But India has been silent whenever relations between Bangladesh and Myanmar have gone sour. And now India wants a defence deal? Let's return to the barbed-wire fence India is building around Bangladesh. We have all seen the examples of Nepal and Sri Lanka. The Bay of Bengal is Bangladesh's prime concern because it is the country's supply line. When Bangladesh has tensions with Myanmar and India helps Myanmar develop its military capacity, it is natural that Bangladesh will protect its own interest.

What is India's relationship with Myanmar?

Their relationship is stronger than ever. India is helping Myanmar to build its armed forces' capacity. We were on the brink of war with Myanmar several times, but instead of playing the role of mediator, India did nothing. It left Bangladesh to fend for itself.Three Indian navy ships, INS Teer, INS Sujata, INS Baruna, leave Chittagong naval base after completing a courtesy visit to Bangladesh on November 15, 2016 ISPR Three Indian navy ships, INS Teer, INS Sujata, INS Baruna, leave Chittagong naval base after completing a courtesy visit to Bangladesh on November 15, 2016 ISPR

Do you think the prime minister will agree to a deal?

The prime minister of Bangladesh is a judicious, highly diplomatic and confident leader. The problem is not with the prime minister. The problem is that there are many groups with vested interests whose advice may compromise the national interest. I believe the honourable prime minister will handle this issue very carefully.

What vested interests?

There are many types – people concerned with power or money. Unfortunately we belong to a political culture where everybody wants to take advantage. We need to think about the political equations at play. One thing we should remember is that there was a lot of controversy over the 2014 general elections. But India supported that election and its results. Now at this stage if India says Bangladesh needs free and fair elections, we have reason to have doubts about what is going on. We should not link Teesta with defence either.
Also Read- China, India in competition to woo Bangladesh for defence deal

If a defence deal becomes a reality, what might be the result?

A defence deal may give India short-term benefits, but not long term ones. Indian foreign policy in this neighbourhood has had few successes because of its insensitivity to public perceptions in neighbouring countries. Sometimes India ignores what the people of Nepal, Sri Lanka or Bangladesh think. That is not a strategy for success. Given India’s regional relations and for India’s own interest, India should take more time in signing an MoU or structured deal with Bangladesh.

Will Bangladesh’s security be harmed by a deal?

Probably not. If reports of a provision in a supposed MoU are accurate that we will jointly produce arms or procure arms from India, that will be not be acceptable. Indian military equipment and weaponry are of a low quality. India's own media has reported on this several times. We need to rely on our credible suppliers. Having said that, Indian training facilities are very good and our officers already enjoy access to them. This does not require a defence agreement.

If a deal is struck, will Bangladesh's relations with China be hampered?

It will have profound implications for China, without doubt. A deal will put pressure on Bangladesh. India has always seen the Bangladesh-China relationship as a strategic threat. India is obsessed with Bangladesh’s submarines. China will be cautious, but it is more interested in the Sino-Bangladesh economic relationship than in a strategic relationship. The Bangladesh-China relationship is economic, but a number of quarters in India believe that it is becoming more strategic. A defence deal will cause China to see the Bangladesh-India and Bangladesh-China relationship through a strategic lens. If that happens, we will definitely see an arms race in the region.Bangladesh Naval officers line up in front of a pair of newly commissioned Chinese submarines – “Nabajatra” and “Joyjatra” – that were added to the nation’s naval fleet at Chittagong Port on March 12, 2017 Focus Bangla Bangladesh Naval officers line up in front of a pair of newly commissioned Chinese submarines – “Nabajatra” and “Joyjatra” – that were added to the nation’s naval fleet at Chittagong Port on March 12, 2017 Focus Bangla

Could a defence deal have a positive impact?

We need to remember that the military doctrines of the two countries are different.
Also Read- Submarines lead Bangladesh navy into new waters

Could you elaborate on that?

Sure. India’s military doctrine is limited offensive. Bangladesh's is purely defensive. Bangladeshi military doctrine is conventional, not nuclear. We use our forces for solely defensive purposes. India’s main concern is Pakistan. It is concerned with war, which we are not. The goals and preparation of the two armies are different. Because the agendas of the two countries are different, it is difficult to find common ground. Bangladesh offers great prospects for India. There have been bilateral successes: India signed the Land Boundary Agreement. But one should not forget that it took India four decades to do so, even though Bangabandhu signed it immediately. India's defence agreement with the United States took 10 years to agree to. We should not rush anything through in a few months.
Top Brokers