Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

HC advises petitioner to move to SC

Update : 13 Feb 2017, 04:13 PM
Justice Farid filed the petition as his job was not regularised after discharging as additional judge of High Court for two years, and his name was excluded – even after reportedly being recommended by the chief justice – from a job confirmation list published through a gazette notification last week by the Ministry of Law, Justice and Parliamentary Affairs. The HC bench of Justice Moyeenul Islam Chowdhury and Justice JBM Hassan came up with the order with a number of observations.
‘Justice ABM Altaf Hossain’s petition is pending with the Appellate Division. So, the HC said that Justice Farid Ahmed Shibli’s petition should also be dealt there’
It said there is a similar petition pending with the Appellate Division, filed by non-confirmed Justice ABM Altaf Hossain on the same ground. On February 12, ten people were appointed as additional judge of HC Division for two years. Last week the Law Ministry issued a gazette notification finalising eight appointments, leaving out Justice Farid Ahmed Shibli and Justice JN Deb Choudhury, who had already died. Justice Farid then filed the petition, seeking a ruling on the government asking as to why the non-confirmation of his job will not be declared illegal. With the petition, he attached a newspaper report that said the chief justice had recommended the names of nine additional judges including Justice Farid to be confirmed as HC Division judges. But his name was dropped by the ministry which is a violation of the verdict of “ten judges’ case.” The case mentioned by the HC was filed in 2003 after the job of 10 judges were not confirmed by the then government. The verdict ruled that in the process of appointing HC Division judges, the recommendation of the chief justice will get preference to any executive decision. Justice Farid’s petition prayed to the HC to issue a ruling upon the government saying that non-confirmation of his job is a violation of the Constitution’s Article 95, and Masdar Hossain case of separation of judiciary from the executive. The petition also prayed to the HC to issue a ruling asking why directives will not be given to appoint him as justice and why the appointment process of the new judges will not be stopped until his appointment. Lawyer Manzill Murshid, who represented the petitioner during the hearing, told reporters that according to the directives of Appellate Division in the ten judges’ case, the CJ’s recommendations will get primacy in appointing judges. He said the verdict of ten judges’ case directed that the executive division’s decision will get primacy only if the recommended judge is disqualified to be appointed. In that case, the executive division of the government will have to mention why they think that the recommended person is disqualified to be confirmed as HC judge. “Justice ABM Altaf Hossain’s petition is pending with the Appellate Division. So, the HC said that Justice Farid Ahmed Shibli’s petition should also be dealt there,” Manzill said. “The HC said that the Appellate Division has already come up with some observations in the ten Judges’ case. In the matter of such petition, the ten Judges’ case is a classic authority of the Appellate Division,” he said quoting the HC verdict. “We want to wash our hand off the matter,” the High Court order said, adding that the petitioner may agitate the matter before the Appellate Division for review or reconsideration of rations.
Top Brokers