Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Poor coordination marks failed salvage operation

Update : 10 Aug 2014, 09:33 PM

It has been seven days since Pinak 6 capsized in the Padma with around 300 passengers and its position is yet to be located; and with every passing day the poor face of coordination among the authorities is becoming clearer.

As of yesterday, only 46 bodies of dead passengers of Pinak 6 were recovered, and with around 100 more still missing, the authorities yesterday decided to concentrate rescue efforts on locating the position of the launch rather than finding dead bodies.

The place on the riverbed where the launch is thought to have rested is more than 62 feet deep. With waves as strong as 5-6 nautical miles per hour, rescuers have found it really difficult to be sure about anything.

Yesterday, they managed to trace a metallic object on the riverbed that was roughly the same size as Pinak 6; but its position was thought to be some two miles away from where the launch was thought to have sunk.

Authorities are saying they are not sure about the exact place where the vessel sank because the survivors and witnesses have failed to pinpoint the position. That they say is one big reason why they could not yet track the launch.

Coordinator of the rescue operation Captain Nazrul Islam of Bangladesh Navy told the Dhaka Tribune: “The passengers have not clearly identified the exact spot of accident; neither has the local authority. They just gave us a probable area. As a result, we are having to run the operation over a large area of roughly 50sq-km. We are not being able to search the entire area at a time.”

However, there are allegations that the authorities concerned have done virtually everything wrong since the launch capsized.

Instead of a coordinated effort, the fire service, Bangladesh Internal Water Transport Authority (BIWTA) and the navy launched rescue operations of their own. It took the shipping minister four days to hold the first coordination meeting after the accident that is thought to have killed nearly 200 people.

Moreover, the fact that most of the rescue crew do not have proper training for such operations has made things even harder.

Aminur Rasel Babul, leader of a citizens movement for river-route safety, said: “Such accidents require more rescue vessels with survey equipment and trained manpower, which is not available in our country. We also needed to deploy volunteers at the accident site immediately after the accident. But that did not happen either.”

BIWTA’s “ace” rescue vessel Rustom reached the spot nearly 14 hours after the accident. Rustom can only pull up sunken vessels from the bottom of rivers; it does not have any tracing mechanism. So, if the position of a launch is not clear, it has nothing to do.

Soon, search vessel Nirbhik joined Rustom, but BIWTA’s survey vessels Kandari 2 and Jarip 10 – both equipped with modern technologies – were still a couple of days away.

Experts say when Kandari 2 and Jarip 10 reached the spot as late as five days after the accident, strong waves have carried the sunken launch further away from the spot making the search difficult for the two vessels.

Aminur Rasel Babul said: “The authority called the rescue vessel first. Then they called the search vessel Nirbhik, and finally survey vessels Kandari and Jarip. They should have moved all the vessels at the same time.”

Asked why the rescue vessel was sent before locating the launch, BIWTA officials said sending the vessel after any accident was a routine procedure; as locating the launch was taking time, they later decided to send the search and survey vessels.

Both Kandari 2 and Jarip 10 belong to the Chittagong Port Authority. Officials said these two vessels had equipment such as the sub-bottom profiler, multi-beam echo sounder, side scanner, sonar, etc, which are also the latest technologies available in the world.

It was in fact the side scanner that located a metallic object yesterday that had resemblance with the sunken ship. However, all the equipment loses much of its effectiveness if it has to work in rough overhead conditions, especially strong waves and decreased visibility due to muddy water.

Port officials also said the two vessels had never been used before for the purpose of locating a capsized launch.

Brig Gen Ali Ahmed Khan, director general of Fire Service and Civil Defence, said: “We need more logistic support for the fire service to run rescue operations smoothly. The staff need to be trained, too. Moreover, there must be smooth coordination among the authorities to ensure smooth rescue operation after any kind of accident.”

Captain Nazrul Islam admitted that they had not thought about using the latest technology at first. He said had they used the technology immediately after the accident, the rescue operation would have taken much less time.

Records from the Department of Shipping show that over the past two decades, at least 392 capsizes have claimed 3,567 lives and left 401 people missing. At least 56 launches that have sunk at various times have never been pulled out of the riverbeds while 12 others have never been traced at all.

There are allegations that most of these launches were left abandoned because of a lack of modern technology.

The Dhaka Tribune has learned that at least 2,500 boats and cargo vessels of various sizes had gone under water at different times and the authorities never took any steps to recover them.

However, the BIWTA has recently invited a tender to pull up 26 water vessels from under water. Of them, 10 are launches and others are ferries and barges.

Shipping Minister Shajahan Khan yesterday told the Dhaka Tribune: “If any sunken vessel does not cause any harm, we do not consider pulling it up. Those water vessels need to be pulled up because they are hampering navigation.”

Top Brokers