Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

EGYPTAIR LEASE SCAM

ACC files case against 23 Biman officials

Of the accused, 13 officials are currently working at Biman


Update : 06 Feb 2023, 09:15 PM

The Anti-Corruption Commission (ACC) has filed a case against 23 officials of Biman Bangladesh airlines over alleged irregularities in the processing of two Egypt aircraft-777-200 ER in 2009-14 that cost the national flag carrier a loss to the tune of over Tk1,100 crore.

Of the accused, 13 officials are currently working at Biman.

ACC Deputy Director Jasmine Akhter filed the case with the commission's integrated district office-1 on Monday. 

According to the case, through premeditated connivance and misuse of power, the accused first confirmed leasing two planes from EgyptAir and later withdrew Tk1,161 crore from the aircraft till re-delivery and embezzled the money by enjoying it among themselves.

They decided to go for the lease under an interim Biman fleet requirement plan (2012-13FY to 2019-20FY) as part of Biman's 10-year business plan (2013-2023). 

The accused were sued under Sections 109/409/420 of the Penal Code and Section 5(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1947.

They are Biman's former director of Flight Operations Captain Ishrat Ahmed, Deputy Engineer Shafiqul Alam Siddique, General Manager Abdur Rahman Farooqui, Chief Engineer Shahid Uddin Mohammad Hanif, former chief engineer Debesh Chowdhury, Airworthiness Consultant (CAAB) Golam Sarwar, Engineer Sadekul Islam Bhuiya, DGM Kamal Uddin Ahmed, Chief Engineer ARM Kaiser Zaman, System Engineer Sharif Ruhul Quddus, Captain Nazrul Islam Shamim, Zia Ahmed, Chief Purser Kazi Mosaddek Ali, Flight Purser Shahidullah Kaiser Duke, Deputy General Manager Md. Azad Rahman, Manager Abdul Qadir, Deputy Chief Engineer Shahjahan, Engineer Officer Zahid Hossain, Assistant Manager Fazlul Haque Basunia, Manager Ataur Rahman, Chief Purser Mohammad Sajjad ul Haque, Flight Purser Shahnaz Begum Jharna, and Chief Engineer Gazi Mahmud Iqbal.

How it happened

The lease decision was taken at the 116th board meeting of Biman. Later, a circular was published inviting tenders for aircraft lease on September 13, 2013.  The tender was opened on December 30. 

A total of four bidders -- Jesco Aviation, USA; Euro Atlantic, Portugal; Standard Chartered, UK; and Egypt Air Holding Co – participated in the bidding. 

Earlier, the Techno Financial Sub-Committee, comprising 14 members under the chairmanship of the Director (Eng), Wing Commander MM Asaduzzaman, responded to EgyptAir Holding Co and submitted its report on December 23. 

In the report, a comparative discussion of the four bidders shows that the other three bidders were the best aircraft suppliers in the world.

Responsive in the financial category as the lowest bidder, EgyptAir was considered the first lowest bidder, while Standard Chartered was the second lowest.

Among them, EgyptAir's engine was made by P&W (Pratt & Whitney company), and was very old. It had a technical glitch, while spare parts are very difficult to collect. On the other hand, Standard Chartered's engine (Rolls Royce Trent company) was much better than EgyptAir's.

However, the commission found that though Standard Chartered was a globally renowned company and the immediate lowest bidder, the accused ignored it instead of making use of negotiation opportunities. Moreover, the Standard Chartered aircraft was in operation by Singapore Airlines, while EgyptAir had remained unused for seven months.

Despite these drawbacks, Biman decided to take the lease from EgyptAir Holding Co.

On April 24 last year, the Parliamentary Standing Committee on the Ministry of Civil Aviation and Tourism recommended the investigation, as the ministry did not follow up on the investigation report.

The parliamentary watchdog asked the ACC to investigate the matter and take legal action.

Biman lost over 1,100C

According to the parliamentary body, the national flag carrier lost Tk1,161 crore as the two aircraft were leased from EgyptAir in 2014.

After operating a flight in February 2015, the engines of one aircraft were damaged. To keep it running, Biman rented another engine from EgyptAir.

However, after a year and a half, the rented engine was also damaged. Following this, Biman rented another engine but it was subsequently damaged.

The last engine was sent to another company in the United States for servicing without a timeline on how long it would take to fix it, said ACC sources.

Heston lease scam probe yet to start

A syndicate reportedly led by Biman Director (Corporate Planning and Training) Mahbub Jahan Khan signed an agreement with the Lithuania-based Heston Airlines, which was approved at the Biman's 276th board meeting, held on April 30 last year.

Mahbub Jahan said that he had prepared guidelines on how to lease aircraft in the future. At a meeting, he spoke in favour of Heston Airlines so that the lease agreement could be finalized with Heston this year.

Former Biman board chairman Sajjadul Hasan and former Biman MD Abu Saleh Mostafa Kamal supported Mahbub Jahan's lease proposals at the meeting on May 3. However, former Biman Board director Abdur Rouf Talukder, who is now Bangladesh Bank governor, opposed the proposal.

Later, State Minister for Civil Aviation and Tourism Md Mahbub Ali also rejected all lease proposals over irregularities.

Top Brokers