Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Ballot papers only in next national election

Uncertainty over Tk1,259 crore that the EC had sought from the Finance Ministry to repair the EVMs was a major reason for the decision, says EC secretary 

Update : 03 Apr 2023, 11:07 PM

The Election Commission (EC) has decided to only use ballot papers for all 300 parliamentary seats up for grabs in the next general election.

The decision was taken at a meeting chaired by Chief Election Commissioner Kazi Habibul Awal at the EC headquarters in Agargaon, Dhaka on Monday.

Collected

Election Commissioner Ahsan Habib Khan told this reporter the EC had decided to only use ballot papers due to the lack of political consensus over the use of EVMs, as well as a crunch in funding. The decision was announced after it received a green signal from the government.

EC secretary Md Jahangir Alam said uncertainty over Tk1,259 crore that the EC had sought from the Finance Ministry to repair the EVMs was a major reason for the decision.

However, EVMs will still be used in the five city corporation elections that are going to be held ahead of the general election.

When asked why EVMs would be used in the city polls when they will not be used in the general election, the EC secretary declined to comment.

On August 23 last year, the EC decided to use EVMs instead of traditional ballot papers in a maximum of 150 constituencies in the next general election, slated to be held early next year.

On September 19, 2022, the EC approved a Tk 8,711 crore project to procure Electronic Voting Machines for 150 constituencies, out of 300, for the 12th parliamentary election.

Ex-commissioners stress transparency in polls

Several former election commissioners said the current EC would struggle to arrange the polls by using traditional ballot papers as the decision to backtrack on EVMs shows the lack of a proper election roadmap and planning.

They added that using ballot papers alone is not enough to ensure transparent and participatory polls.

“The electoral process has to be transparent, but how transparent depends on how far the electoral legal framework allows,” said Dr Md Rafiqul Islam, a former election commissioner and secretary.

He said the legal framework includes the Constitution, acts, ordinances, rules, regulations, as well as codes. The EC has to comply with all of these and ensure they are implemented.

“Transparency depends on the legal framework, and it cannot be ensured by the EC alone,” he added.

He also pointed out that it is challenging for the EC to monitor the legal framework and implement electoral procedures as it requires a significant amount of manpower with skills in various fields.

Dr Md Rafiqul Islam said: “If people involved in the electoral process are motivated and self-inspired, it is a really difficult job to make the election process transparent. As per democratic norms, if more than 50% voters voluntarily participate in an election, it is marked as a participatory election. Still, the scope for raising questions exists. Were all the parties involved in the election? If the answer is no, anyone can call it not participatory.”

He added that the EC can do little to ensure participation as the decision ultimately rests with the parties themselves.

“Whatever happens, if the election is acceptable to voters, observers, and supporters, only then can it be called transparent and participatory,” the former election commissioner noted.

Former election commissioner Brig Gen Dr Sakhawat Hussain, who is currently a senior fellow at the South Asian Institute of Policy and Governance (SIPG) of North South University, said: "A proper plan should be in place one year before the elections. If the commission wants to arrange elections on ballot papers, then it has to prepare various things, including paper, ink, and seals."

He feared the EC would face shortages due to the sudden switch to paper ballots, as there is little time to arrange imports.

Top Brokers