If you visit the official website of the Bangladesh Government, you will see a few apps listed as “necessary apps” including Bangladesh Directory (for Android and iOS), Bangladesh Tourist Spot, Uttoradhikar, and Ogrojatra (Election Manifesto). But how many of these apps fulfill their true purposes is a real question.
If you browse through the Bangladesh Directory app, you will notice different sections that hold supposed contact information of important personnels. After using the app for only a little while, you will be able to see what is wrong with it. Many of the information are incorrect while some are quite vague.
For example, if you scroll through the BGB section, you will see a person named Rob pops up who supposedly has a contact number that is surprisingly presumptuous. His phone number is: 1234567. Most of these apps were developed with technical help from the ICT division, a2i, Cabinet Division, or the UNDP.
Another Government app developed by a2i, named EkPay is claimed to serve the purpose of digital payments, like bill payments through cards, or bank transactions. It has a download number of 10K+ with an average rating of 2.8 stars. The problem with the app is that the billing information doesn't get updated even once you pay the bill. A similar problem was faced by a reviewer, who wrote, “Poor performance. DESCO meter was not recharged but amount was deducted from account.”
Do any of these apps work?
The general idea behind a successful app is the proper implementation of its purpose. From this perspective, the most successful Government app is undoubtedly the Surokkha app. The app has a 5M+ number of downloads with a 4.3 star rating. Romana Khan, a housewife from Dhaka, said, “The Surokkha app is very easy to use. The app produced my data and I could successfully register for the vaccine.”
Although questions can be raised about how the app was failing multiple times whenever it got overflowed with traffic. Some people even complained that they noticed glitches in the app.
How many unsuccessful apps are still there?
Did you know that BD Sugar and Food Industries is an app? It was developed in 2015, and has not received an update since 2016. If you open the app, you will notice a homepage that is supposed to lead you to information on this field. But if you click on the avatars, it doesn't work anymore.
The Hospital Finder app is an application to find nearby hospitals around the user. If you open the app, a Google map of the streets pops up. But due to its incorrect location detector, it won't be able to produce results of nearby hospitals, failing in its only purpose.
The NBR Tax Calculator is another app that calculates total amount of taxes based on user input. Unfortunately, the app is stuck in the year 2016-17, and cannot be used to calculate the tax anymore. It could prove useful if only it was updated with time.
There were a total of 600 apps developed in the time period between 2013 to 2015, which took an estimated budget of 18.35 crores. All of these apps fall under these two projects. Only 44 of them are still available online.
Around 300 of the 600 apps created by two projects were designed to allow people to directly access the services of specific government offices or agencies. Although most of them have since become obsolete, some apps have been developed on the agencies' own initiative.
Where is the rest of the world in digital transformation?
The Covid-19 pandemic has spurred worldwide digital transformation, but possibly nowhere more drastically than in Asia-Pacific. In Southeast Asia, more than 40 million individuals went online for the first time in 2020, while India alone added 47 million internet users in South Asia.
Meanwhile, the Asia-Pacific region experienced a significant increase in the creation, acceptance, and usage of digital technologies, including new e-commerce, remote work, and digital healthcare applications. A recent McKinsey analysis revealed that nations in this area witnessed an average seven years' worth of growth in digital products and services in 2020 compared to what had been expected.
According to a 2021 analysis by the IMD Business School, some nations have risen to the upper echelons of digital transformation, whilst others must progress before they can truly shine. The rankings are based on a combination of real facts and survey answers. The hard data shows the performance in 2020, while the poll was conducted from February to May 2021. The most significant instruments for resolving the difficulties of the health crisis and economic volatility have been knowledge, technology, and future preparation.
What is obstructing us from reaching similar results?
The main culprit behind Bangladesh's poor digital footprint is the absence of a smart infrastructure. Many of the people still face difficulties accessing the web. Some have negligible digital literacy. The slow internet speed is a huge factor as well. If we look at the smartphone penetration rate in comparison to our neighboring countries, the difference becomes clear at a glance.
Lack of skilled workforce
We cannot deny that the changing world demands the development of young people with new talents that are consistent with new realities and viewpoints. As a result, the need for young individuals with such talents will inevitably rise.
Upskilling a people has a direct influence on the economy and society. Singapore, for example, was placed second in the GCI 2020, with a per capita income of USD 60,000. This has been made feasible by the Smart Nation Singapore initiative's execution.
Similarly, Thailand and Indonesia are reaping the benefits of digitization and policy emphasis on upskilling. With such a program, Indonesia has effectively become the largest economy in Southeast Asia, with a GDP of more than USD 1.1 trillion.
According to the conclusions of the 2021 Global Data Market Opportunity Study, IaaS (Infrastructure as a Service) would be the fastest growing category, with Asia Pacific accounting for 80% of the entire market share by the end of 2024. In such a case, digital inclusion will fuel growth in a variety of businesses in the near future.
This fact is also important for Bangladesh, where enormous changes in the industry environment have occurred in recent years as a result of the country's massive digital transformation.
Corruption
The contradicting findings depict a picture of a multi-year, multimillion-dollar drive that is not being allowed to reach its full potential. Nobody expects Bangladesh to have the same degree of digital capacity as developed nations. However, corruption, nepotism, and inefficiency, whether of the system or the people who run it, are concerns that a good infrastructure alone cannot address. Because of these recurring challenges, digitalization has not proven to be the great asset that was predicted.
Lack of a central monitoring system
Unfortunately, our e-office and e-government frameworks appear to be in their infancy. There is no defined guideline for digital transformation, no central monitoring authority for all digital services, and no centralized data storage to simplify all the information going through the system, such as NID, TIN, e-passport, birth, land, car, or other registration records.
Data consumption and sharing are just as vital as data digitization. But ours is an island of misfit agencies, each with its own digital architecture and minimal interconnection. Ministers talk of digitizing all 2,800 public services, but they rarely address the governance challenges that might hinder their effectiveness.
Return of Investment
Return of Investment (ROI) is commonly defined as the ratio of net profit to total investment cost. ROI is most relevant to your company goals when it refers to something solid and measurable, such as identifying the profits and financial returns of your investment.
Unfortunately the Government projects in 2013 to 2015 cost crores of taka but failed to produce marginal profit. Most of the apps are taken down. The few remaining ones are in a sorry state, full of bugs, waiting for an update. It is only a matter of time that they will be taken down, if kept in this state. Expecting a profit from them is just ironic at this point.
External fund
Since the outset, the United Nations Development Programme (UNDP) has consistently provided support through policy guidelines and active cooperation. So when State Minister for Information and Communication Technology Junaid Ahmed Palak expresses his confidence about pushing the country's digital transformation to the next level with the execution of the UNDP's 'Digital Strategy 2022-25,' the possibility appears promising. The UNDP's active participation in the process ensured that the country successfully navigated the various routes of this new sector.
Similarly, the UNDP supported the Partnerships for a Tolerant and Inclusive Bangladesh (PTIB), the Human Rights Programme (HRP), and Youth CO:Lab in bringing the benefits of modern technology to the targeted recipients.
All of these programs did not produce the best outcomes, but they did shine light on areas that need to be reviewed. However, the most significant contribution these programs produced was the motivation for breaking down the psychological barrier and bringing previously uneducated and even illiterate individuals within the reach of digital services.
What are the American companies doing?
The North American digital transformation market was valued at $166.07 billion in 2017, and it is expected to grow by 22.1% to $757.63 billion by 2025.
As many professional American firms see this as a key aspect of maximizing their business, they are utilizing digital transformation and other equipment to get a competitive advantage.
Companies utilize four important strategies to properly capitalize on this opportunity: big data, social media, IoT, mobility, and cloud computing.
The increasing popularity of social media, improved internet penetration, and rising concern in data protection have provided an opportunity for the US-based digital transformation business by allowing firms to broaden their consumer base.
Seeking professional help
If a country is to genuinely embrace the potentials presented by technological transformation, it must have strong boards and CEO-level sponsorships in different sectors.
A digital culture is becoming increasingly vital for corporate success; leadership is responsible for cultivating that culture. Gathering information on processes and personalities at the early stage is critical for gaining confidence and adoption for digital transformation.
This will aid in the mapping and prioritization of future modifications and consequences. With that mapping, we will be able to identify areas of risk for both the digital transformation transition process and its consequences. This will increase the country's visibility, resulting in increased trust and willingness. Finally, begin workshops and training as soon as possible.
Citizens have varying levels of technological competence, thus the more people get engaged, the greater the advocacy and knowledge a country will have during the digital transformation process.
Ahmed Shoyeb Iqbal is the Head of Operations (COO), Ecommerce, Retail & Media of Gemcon Group