Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

China, Nepal take first steps towards proposed rail link from Tibet to Kathmandu

Beijing has said that it will begin and fund a feasibility study for the ambitious railway project within a year

Update : 28 Sep 2022, 07:16 PM

On August 10, China announced that it will start a feasibility study for the ambitious Tibet-Nepal Railway project within a year. The announcement during Nepal foreign minister Narayan Khadka’s visit to China also revealed that China would pay for the study.

The proposed 170-kilometre railway, part of the Belt and Road Initiative, will link Kerung in southern Tibet to Nepal’s capital Kathmandu, entering Nepal in Rasuwa district. The plan is to extend the railway to India eventually.

People familiar with the matter told The Third Pole that building the railway from Kerung to Kathmandu would cost about $5.5 billion, almost equal to total government revenues for the country in 2018. Although only one-third of the full length falls on the Nepal side, this stretch would account for almost half of the costs due to the complex geology and climate.

The estimated cost of the feasibility study has not been made public, but China has announced that it will provide $118 million to Nepal in 2022.

Experts say this could be a defining move for the Tibet-Nepal Railway, which has been on hold for years with Nepal reluctant to fund the study and China reticent about financing it.

“The feasibility study will do two important things: first, it will determine the route, including ground and bridge proportion. And second, [it will determine] the type of railway that needs to be built – high speed or slow,” said Paribesh Parajuli, an engineer who worked as a consultant at the Department of Railways until 2019.

In late 2018, China prepared a pre-feasibility study of the railway for Nepal. It estimated the cost of the 72.5-km section in Nepal at $2.75 billion. The report, which is not yet publicly available, suggested it was a complicated project but not impossible.

“Technically, this will be one of the world’s toughest railways to construct as it needs to cross the lofty and fragile Himalayan range, but with China’s technological prowess it is possible as they have already built railways in higher altitudes in Tibet than the proposed Nepal-China railway,” said Aman Chitrakar, spokesperson for Nepal’s Department of Railways.

He added that the pre-feasibility study was carried out just by a Chinese team as Nepal cannot carry out any technical works on railways. The same will happen with the feasibility study. “It’s their money, and their expertise will be key, but we hope to be consulted during the study,” he said.

But some worry about Nepal’s lack of ability even to review technical reports as it does not have railway engineers. The department established a decade ago is dominated by road engineers.

“It was OK to rely fully on the Chinese for a pre-feasibility study as it was more of a kind of survey, but the feasibility study is a key project document if it’s going to be implemented, and Nepal must have serious eyes on it,” said Paribesh Parajuli, who is among handful of railways engineers in the country – none of whom work for the government.

Nepal, which built its first railway in 1927 near its border with India, had no railway department until 2011 and is yet to hire railway engineers to staff the department.

In 2018 – the same year as the pre-feasibility study – the Nepal Department of Railways and China Railway signed a memorandum of understanding to foster cooperation, according to Chitrakar. But the Department of Railways was not informed by its own foreign ministry about any developments during China’s foreign minister Wang Yi’s visit in March and Nepal’s foreign minister’s visit in August.

“We heard that our government had signed a memorandum of understanding on technical schemes of the railway project during Wang Yi’s visit in March and now media reports have said a feasibility study will be carried out, but as an implementing agency we haven’t been informed about any developments that were made in the recent months,” said Chitrakar.

Top Brokers