Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Doing the math on the Rohingya crisis

Update : 10 Nov 2017, 09:04 AM
While the Bangladesh government has taken swift steps to get to grips with the Rohingya crisis, there has been much speculation about the economic costs stemming from hosting such a huge population over an indefinite period of time. So far, in financial terms, the Bangladesh government has not had to spend a huge amount to host the Rohingya people. As part of the government’s plans to relocate the Rohingya to the island of Bhasan Char in Noakhali, Bangladesh Navy has been allotted Tk10 crore to develop roads and a helipad there. Furthermore, another Tk3.15 crore has been allocated to erect fences in the makeshift camps in Cox’s Bazar. The Prime Minister’s Office is also providing financial assistance to an extent. Ministry of Finance officials say the current allocations will have no impact on the current national budget. But it is only because other countries and aid agencies have been providing relief worth millions to the Rohingya in Bangladesh. These amounts however do not account for the huge social and economic cost the crisis has had on the local economy. So far, 3500 acres of forest land have been destroyed in setting up the makeshift camps. By September this year, price of essentials in local markets had doubled in Teknaf and Ukhiya. On Monday, Finance Minister AMA Muhith said: “Some ministries and divisions have asked us for funds between Tk4 crore ($480,000) and Tk10 crore ($1.2 million) for the Rohingya people. With donations from other countries and agencies, it has not affected the budget much.” He further said Bangladesh needs a major push from development partners to introduce new projects to take care of the Rohingyas in the long run if some of them are not able go back to Myanmar. But when Muhith was in New York in October, he said that Bangladesh had to drastically revise the budget to adjust for the Rohingya crisis. Finance Division officials initially estimated the development of Bhasan Char would cost Tk1,000 crore ($120 million). But with more Rohingya refugees in the country, and more recent reports on the island, the estimates have more than doubled to Tk2,500 crore ($300 million). The majority of the cost will go towards building dykes around the island to protect it from flooding. Furthermore, several officials have said that countries which are providing humanitarian support are not inclined to provide infrastructural support. The government’s Fiscal Coordination Council is set to convene soon to discuss the matter.

Adding the numbers

According to a rough estimation by Policy Research Institute (PRI), a local think tank, it would cost $800 million to $1 billion to provide a minimum and only basic services. The estimation has been forecast based on the Bangladesh's per capita income, which proposed to allocate 70% of income of a citizen. According to Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics (BBS) latest data, Bangladesh's per capita income stood at $1,602. According to a UN assessment, $434 million is required for the rehabilitation of Rohingyas in six months. “The current estimate stands at $800 million to $1 billion a year for the refugees: up to 70% of Bangladesh’s income per capita,” Ashikur Rahman, a senior economist of Policy Research Institute (PRI), told the Dhaka Tribune. “This is a conservative estimate, which would provide only for basic services.” Debapriya Bhattacharya, a distinguished fellow at the Centre for Policy Dialogue (CPD), said there are two types of costs involved in providing the stricken Rohingya with essential services: direct and indirect. “Direct costs include food and health services while indirect costs are incurred by the community and environment,” he said. Dr AB Mirza Azizul Islam, former advisor to the caretaker government, told the Dhaka Tribune that it is the food and lodging which will prove costly. He said: “If we are to increase budget allocation for relief, we have to cut down on development projects.” Dr Selim Raihan, executive director of South Asian Network on Economic Modeling, said: “We agree with PRI’s findings that taking care of the Rohingya will cost more than Tk8,000 crore annually. Who will pay for this?” Dr Selim added: “If we use World Bank's ‘moderate’ poverty line income of $3.1 per person per day, and if the number of Rohingya refugees is one million, it will mean the cost of maintaining them could be Tk9,000 crore ($1 billion) annually.” He noted that donor countries and agencies have borne the bulk of the expenses for now, but the future could be very grim if Bangladesh is compelled to bear the expenditure. So far Malaysia, Turkey, Denmark, Australia, Netherlands, Azerbaijan among others have extended support to the Rohingya refugees. International charity organisations like Oxfam and Red Cross have also stepped up. The donation has been diverse – from nation states to humanitarian agencies to charitable individuals – all have come forward with whatever they can. Vivian Tan, a UNHCR official, recently said that the 607,000 Rohingya refugees who have fled to Bangladesh since August need immediate assistance costing Tk641.25 crore ($77 million). The Red Cross and Red Crescent pledged to respond to the need for help and pledged to appeal to 190 countries. Secretary General Mazharul Haque said they have collected Tk101.56 crores already, with Denmark promising Tk25 crore, Australia Tk41.5 crore and Kuwait pledging Tk12.45 crore.
Top Brokers