Neat certainties are rare in the North Korean nuclear crisis, which for decades has simmered and occasionally boiled over, without resolution.
So it was jarring to see the absolute confidence with which US top Pacific commander described the ability of a contentious US missile defence system, scheduled to be up and running in days in South Korea, to shoot down North Korean missiles.
"If it flies, it will die," Adm Harry Harris Jr told US lawmakers at a hearing Wednesday.
THAAD has limits, unknowns
After an early redesign, the Terminal High-Altitude Area Defence system, THAAD, was reportedly successfully tested 12 times, according to Jonathan McDowell, an astrophysicist at the Harvard-Smithsonian Centre for Astrophysics.
A controlled test, however, is a much different matter than an actual war, where large numbers of missiles will be fired with little or no warning.
A salvo of multiple North Korean short-range missiles, for instance, could overwhelm THAAD, said David Wright, co-director of the Union of Concerned Scientists' Global Security Program.
THAAD will also be deployed about 200km south of Seoul, whose greater metropolitan area, about an hour from the heavily armed border, is home to 25 million. "It cannot engage missiles fired at Seoul, so it offers no additional protection of the city," Wright said.
Some scientists are even blunter.
Harris' comments about THAAD's capabilities "are technically incorrect," said Theodore Postol, a professor at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology. "The THAAD interceptor is very easily defeated by either causing a missile to tumble end over end, or by intentionally fragmenting a rocket into pieces."
US THAAD anti-missile deployment in S. Korea sparks clashes between locals & police DETAILS: https://t.co/PI55LGPYVs pic.twitter.com/Nr9rKSJX32
— RT (@RT_com) April 26, 2017
The political angle
A senior military official briefing lawmakers beholden to US taxpayers must show complete confidence in the very expensive piece of hardware that's about to be deployed in a skittish US ally living in direct range of North Korean missiles. "Just imagine an Air Force general saying that his new jetfighters, designed for air superiority, will not stand a chance against the enemy fighters," said Markus Schiller, a missile specialist in Germany. "The same is true for a missile defence system, once deployed, the commanding officer has to say it will work." THAAD is a big issue ahead of the May 9 presidential election, with the leading candidate, liberal Moon Jae-in, vowing to reconsider the deployment if he wins. Some South Koreans wonder why the US and the caretaker government that took over for recently removed President Park Geun-hye rushed key parts of THAAD into place before dawn this week, prompting violent clashes between local villagers and police.This is South Koreans response to the deployment of US #Thaad systems. They know what's coming with 45 pic.twitter.com/WFAI5zThyT— Almost Sober Bannon (@GreatTrump1) April 26, 2017
The China angle
Beijing says THAAD's powerful radar can be reconfigured to peer deep into its territory and monitor its flights and missile launches.
Seoul already sees moves by Beijing to retaliate, including limits on Chinese tour group visits to South Korea, which is increasingly dependent on Chinese tourism and demand for its industrial products.
Some experts are sympathetic with China's argument.
Postol said THAAD's radar can track Chinese intercontinental ballistic missiles flying below the curved earth horizon of US missile defence radars in Alaska. It could then send and receive critical missile defence information to US monitors.



