The latest revised draft of the COP31 cover decision has sparked fresh controversy after dropping explicit references to accelerating the transition away from fossil fuels and implementing the Belém Gender Action Plan, exposing deep divisions among countries over the summit's climate ambitions.
The revised text, circulated by the COP31 Presidency on Thursday afternoon, also removes references to persons with disabilities, narrows commitments on climate-related health impacts and leaves several critical issues unresolved as the summit approaches its scheduled conclusion on Friday.
While the draft retains a call to at least triple adaptation finance by 2035, it does not establish an agreed baseline for measuring the increase, raising questions about how the commitment will be implemented and monitored.
The developments have drawn criticism from climate advocates and vulnerable countries, who fear that political compromises are weakening accountability and undermining the interests of communities already experiencing the consequences of climate change.
Panama has emerged as one of the strongest critics of the revised language. Environment Minister Juan Carlos Navarro warned that his country would formally object at the closing plenary if the final outcome failed to meet its principles.
In a letter outlining Panama's demands, Navarro called for a cap on global oil production at current levels, immediate action on methane emissions, recognition of science as the foundation of climate policy and changes to the UN climate decision-making process to allow majority voting.
At a separate press conference, Navarro accused the petroleum industry of holding the world hostage.
"We are in love with our kidnappers," he said, describing governments' continued dependence on fossil fuel industries.
He also said 30 countries now supported efforts to develop a fossil fuel treaty outside the UN climate negotiations.
Adaptation finance pledge faces questions over implementation
One of the central elements of the revised draft is its call to increase adaptation finance, but the absence of an agreed baseline has created uncertainty over the scale of the commitment.
The document estimates that developing countries will require approximately $305 billion annually for adaptation through 2035.
It asks the Standing Committee on Finance to present options for establishing a baseline in 2027 against which progress towards tripling adaptation finance can be measured.
A separate provision calls for efforts to at least triple annual outflows from specified multilateral climate funds by 2030, using 2022 as the baseline.
Teresa Anderson of ActionAid International said developing countries were being expected to undertake greater climate adaptation efforts without receiving adequate financial support.
"Adaptation is how we all survive this climate crisis together," she told journalists.
The proposed Antalya-to-Addis Ababa Roadmap on Adaptation and Resilience Finance is intended to identify predictable funding sources and improve countries' access to climate finance, including resources for addressing loss and damage.
The COP31 and COP32 presidencies would oversee the process and report on progress in 2027.
However, the roadmap does not specify new financial contributions from individual countries, leaving uncertainty over where the additional resources will come from.
The draft encourages greater use of grants and highly concessional public finance, particularly for least developed countries and small island developing states. It also calls on funding institutions to accelerate approvals, reduce transaction costs and simplify requirements for recipient countries.
Loss and damage funding gap widens
The financing gap is particularly visible in the loss and damage mechanism.
According to the draft, funding requests submitted under the Barbados Implementation Modalities amount to approximately $2.8 billion, compared with allocations of only $342 million.
Of the $822 million pledged to the Fund for Responding to Loss and Damage, only around half has been converted into actual contributions.
The draft also acknowledges that the Santiago Network and the Executive Committee of the Warsaw International Mechanism remain under-resourced.
Sandeep Chamling Rai, WWF's global climate change adaptation adviser, said communities already experiencing climate-related losses, including those in Nepal, urgently needed financial support.
He questioned whether the proposed roadmap would provide sufficient assurance that money would reach affected communities in time.
The funding shortfall remains a major concern for vulnerable countries, where climate-related disasters are increasing pressure on livelihoods, infrastructure and public services.
Fossil fuel transition disappears from revised text
The removal of explicit fossil fuel language has become one of the most contentious aspects of the revised cover decision.
The earlier draft circulated on Monday had called for countries to accelerate the transition away from fossil fuels, reflecting the commitment agreed at COP28 in Dubai.
However, Thursday's version no longer contains that explicit call.
Instead, it indirectly refers to the Dubai agreement by encouraging countries to reflect the outcomes of the first Global Stocktake in their national climate and adaptation plans.
Although the COP28 decision remains in force, campaigners fear that removing direct references from the COP31 outcome weakens political momentum towards implementing it.
The revised text also contains no reference to the just transition mechanism that countries agreed to develop at COP30 in Belém.
Negotiations on the mechanism are continuing separately under the Just Transition Work Programme.
Australia's Climate Minister Chris Bowen, who is leading the COP31 negotiations, said countries were considering a two-part structure.
One component would provide political direction, while another would connect countries with technical experts, potential funders and existing initiatives to support the transition towards lower-emission economies.
However, the proposal does not include a commitment to establish a dedicated fund.
Electrification target raises concerns over energy sources
The revised draft proposes that electricity should account for 35% of global final energy consumption by 2035.
The target is linked to efforts to triple renewable energy capacity and double the global average annual rate of energy efficiency improvements by 2030.
However, the text does not establish a minimum share for clean electricity, meaning that additional power generated from coal and gas could also contribute towards the electrification target.
France's Ecological Transition Minister Monique Barbut said her country would push for renewable energy and nuclear power to meet rising electricity demand.
Meanwhile, two proposals concerning carbon capture, utilisation and storage remain in brackets, indicating that countries have yet to reach agreement.
One proposal calls for capturing at least 500 million tonnes of carbon dioxide annually by 2035, while working towards a longer-term range of 1.3 billion to 2.5 billion tonnes.
Another proposes working towards capturing 2.5 billion tonnes annually by 2035.
Vanuatu's Climate Minister Ralph Regenvanu questioned the prominence given to the technology, saying it had received more attention than it deserved.
The draft separately addresses carbon dioxide removal, stating that it should complement deep emissions reductions rather than replace them.
Gender commitments and disability references removed
The revised text has also triggered concerns over the weakening of gender-related commitments and inclusive climate decision-making.
Four diplomats involved in the negotiations told journalists that Russia and the Vatican were seeking to block most references to gender in negotiating texts, while the European Union opposed those efforts.
The word "gender" does not appear anywhere in Thursday's cover draft.
Women are mentioned only once, in a paragraph listing relevant stakeholders.
The earlier draft had explicitly called for women and girls to participate fully in climate decision-making. The revised version also removes any specific role for women-led organisations in proposed annual workshops on access to climate finance between 2027 and 2030.
Although the Belém Gender Action Plan remains in force, campaigners are concerned that its implementation is receiving insufficient political attention.
The revised text also removes the explicit reference to persons with disabilities included in Monday's version.
While it encourages financial institutions to engage vulnerable communities, it does not explain how persons with disabilities will participate in funding decisions or how those processes will be made accessible.
Provisions recognising the importance of youth participation and Indigenous Peoples' leadership have, however, been retained.
The draft recognises intergenerational equity and calls for children and young people to have a meaningful voice in climate decisions. It also acknowledges the environmental stewardship and climate leadership of Indigenous Peoples and local communities.
Health and food security provisions narrowed
The revised document has also narrowed its provisions on climate-related health impacts.
It recognises the growing consequences of climate change for physical and mental health and calls on governments to strengthen health systems by integrating health considerations into national adaptation plans.
However, it contains no dedicated commitment to health financing.
The earlier draft had specifically identified food and nutrition insecurity, damage to health facilities during extreme weather events and the importance of early warning systems for public health.
Those details have been removed from the revised health provision.
Notably, the words "food", "agriculture" and "nutrition" are absent from the document, while farmers are mentioned only once in the stakeholder list.
The text encourages locally led adaptation through sustainable land management, ecosystem restoration and measures to withstand drought, but does not assign farmers a specific role in deciding how adaptation finance should be allocated.
Mountain communities and climate risks
The draft proposes establishing a Work Programme on Mountains and Climate Change under the Nairobi Work Programme.
The initiative would focus on improving climate observations, strengthening early warning systems and reducing disaster risks in mountain regions and glacier-dependent communities.
However, the programme would rely on existing funding channels rather than a dedicated financial mechanism.
The proposal also includes two technical dialogues and a high-level dialogue on mountains at COP32, although some details remain unresolved.
2.6°C warming projection highlights urgency
The draft acknowledges that full implementation of existing national climate plans would put the world on course for approximately 2.6°C of warming.
It also recognises that projected peak warming is likely to exceed the 1.5°C threshold and calls for any overshoot to be as small and brief as possible.
Fernanda de Carvalho, WWF's global head of climate and energy policy, welcomed the attention given to temperature overshoot, oceans and climate science.
However, she urged the COP31 Presidency to carry forward the COP30 roadmaps on fossil fuels and forests.
Outside the negotiating venue, climate activists staged a symbolic protest using missing-cat posters featuring a cat named Ambition to highlight what they described as the disappearance of climate ambition from the negotiations.
Philippine Menager of the Ecología y Desarrollo Foundation said campaigners wanted a clear roadmap for moving away from coal, oil and gas.
With the summit scheduled to conclude on Friday, negotiations remain intense. COP31 negotiation lead Chris Bowen said the Presidency would continue consultations with negotiating groups through Thursday night in an effort to secure consensus.
The final outcome will test whether countries can bridge their differences and deliver commitments that translate into meaningful action for vulnerable communities, or whether political disagreements will once again leave critical climate priorities unresolved.
This story was produced as part of the COP31 Climate Change Media Partnership, a journalism fellowship organised by Internews' Earth Journalism Network, Informed Earth and the Stanley Center for Peace and Security.



