As the world combats the spread of the novel coronavirus, health care experts have continued to debate how to best protect the protectors during a time when they are needed most.
With masks and other supplies dwindling, public health experts are now balancing the need to keep health care workers on the front lines against the need to protect medical staff from becoming patients themselves.
In the outbreak in Wuhan, 1300 health-care workers became infected. The city began to run out of doctors and nurses. Fortunately, methods were found that protected all the new health-care workers, later none were infected.
Wuhan was locked down and cut off from outside visitors, health-care workers seeing at-risk patients were housed away from their families. They wore full-body protective gear, including goggles, complete head coverings, N95 particle-filtering masks, and hazmat-style suits.
There are lessons to be learnled from two places that saw the new coronavirus before and that have had success in controlling its spread. Hong Kong and Singapore detected their first cases in late January, and the number of cases escalated rapidly, reports the New Yorker.
Primary-care clinics and hospitals in the two countries, like in the US, did not have enough gowns and N95 masks, and, at first, tests weren’t widely available. After six weeks, though, they had a handle on the outbreak.
Changing protocols
"We do not feel protected," said Melissa Johnson-Camacho, University of California, Davis nurse and chief nurse representative for the California Nurses Association. "I’ve cried almost every day. I think if there were more transparency, everyone would feel a lot better."
File photo: A health worker in a protective gown checks a man for signs of the coronavirus | Mahmud Hossain Opu/Dhaka TribuneIn February, at the UC-Davis Medical Center, one Covid-19 patient led to the self-quarantine of at least 124 nurses and health care workers, according to the National Nurses United Association, reports ABC News.
"It is now a very different conversation," said Johnson-Camacho. Hospitals, including UC Davis Medical Center, are responding to the evolving situation and have reevaluated and modified their protocols, ensuring that Covid-19 patients are identified at the earliest stages of entry and that frontline workers are protected when they first encounter a suspected Covid-19 patient.
However, even with these new protocols, health care workers say it is not enough and do not feel that these changes are communicated well.
In response to shortages of personal protective equipment (PPE), the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) last week scaled back its recommendations regarding PPE for health care personnel working with Covid-19 patients.
CDC officials no longer recommend that health care workers use N95 respirators around Covid-19 patients at all times, recommending instead that N95 respirators be reserved for procedures in which small particles, known as aerosols, are more likely to be produced, for instance when critically ill patients are intubated to help them breathe.
File photo: A worker in a protective suit examines specimens inside a laboratory following an outbreak of the novel coronavirus in Wuhan, Hubei province, China February 6, 2020 | Reuters
N95 respirators are individually fitted for the user and block out aerosols. Outside of these aerosol-producing procedures, the CDC says that surgical masks -- which are looser fitting and protect from large droplets, splashes and sprays from sneezes and coughs -- are an acceptable alternative form of protection.
The agency also recommends that, in addition to the masks, workers also wear eye protection, gown and gloves.
"When I get off, I pick my kids up, I go to meetings, I volunteer. When nurses are exposed, the public is not safe," said Johnson-Camacho.
"The biggest issue is there is a lot of downplaying when I really think what we want to hear is that, yes, this is serious, yes, patients' lives are important and yes, we are committed to being prepared and keeping you protected," he added.
According to worldometer, more than 307,600 people have so far been infected by Covid-19 and over 13,000 people killed worldwide.



