Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Coronavirus may not be as deadly as previously thought

The current mortality rate estimates may be exaggerating the situation 

Update : 13 Mar 2020, 02:58 PM

Covid-19, better known as the coronavirus, has induced panic all over the world, which has resulted in shortages in hand sanitizer and N95 face masks. 

“Do not hoard masks and food. Figure out how to help seniors and the immunosuppressed stay healthy,” said an op-ed in Slate, an American online magazine.

Initial investigations staked the coronavirus mortality rate at about 2-3%, which is similar to the mortality rate of the Spanish flu, which killed tens of millions of people. However, the true case fatality rate (CFR) of coronavirus is likely to be far lower than current reports suggest.

CFR refers to the proportion of deaths from a certain disease, among those who have been diagnosed with the disease. The author of the op-ed opines that even the one percent death rate recently mentioned by accredited health institutions, is likely overstating the case. 

The most compelling evidence disproving the current reported CFR comes from data from the Diamond Princess cruise outbreak, which lead to the subsequent quarantine of its passengers off the coast of Japan. 

Although unfortunate, a quarantined boat is the ideal environment to study a virus, since we can control many variables. For example, we know that the affected passengers were healthy enough to travel before boarding the cruise, whereas in China, the patients could have already been ill. 

Looking at mortality rates in a general setting is problematic as there is much room for extraneous variables to confound the accuracy of the data. In China, nine million people die each year. A significant portion of these deaths results from diseases like lower respiratory infections or lung cancer, whose symptoms are clinically indistinguishable from the unspecific symptoms seen in severe coronavirus cases. 

During the peak of the outbreak in China, most reported cases were older patients in whom the chronic diseases mentioned above are prevalent. Most deaths occurred in the Hubei province, an area where lung cancer and emphysema incidences are significantly higher than national averages in China, a country where half of all men smoke. 

On the Diamond Princess, only about 19% of the passengers tested positive for the virus—which, considering the confined area and how contagious the virus appears to be, is surprisingly low. Furthermore, there were only six fatalities, which occurred in patients who are more than 70 years old.

All of this information suggests that coronavirus is a relatively benign disease for most young people, and a potentially devastating one for the old and chronically ill, albeit not nearly as risky as reported. 

Therefore, it is necessary to divert our focus away from preventing the spread among healthy people—which is either inevitable or out of our control—and commit most of our resources toward protecting the at-risk demographic. This largely comes down to hygiene, isolation, and social distancing. 

Healthy people who are hoarding food, masks, and hand sanitizer may feel like they are being proactive, but these actions probably represent misdirected anxieties. When such efforts are not directed towards protecting the most susceptible demographics, people may actually be squandering precious and limited resources.

Top Brokers