Below-par umpiring decisions cost Bangladesh heavily as the fearless run from the Tigers in the World Cup ended with a 103-run defeat to India in the quarter-final yesterday, but gave birth to immense doubts in the mind of the cricket fans across the globe.
It was not only the Bangladeshi fans, but general cricket lovers and celebrities also did shy away from expressing their disappointment over the ridiculous decisions from the umpires which helped a limping India gain grip of the high-voltage encounter.
The social media websites were flooded with arrows of criticisms towards the International Cricket Council (ICC) and India’s strong role behind the international cricket body’s activities.
India managed 302 for 6, but as MS Dhoni in the post-match conference said they could have easily been restricted to 250 if Suresh Raina or Rohit Sharma did not contribute largely. Imagine how awful and disheartening was it then for Bangladesh captain Mashrafe bin Mortaza when his side, the ninth ranked ODI team, were denied the wickets of both the batsmen before they launched a late assault.
Raina, who went on to make a 57-ball 65, survived a mighty close leg-before wicket shout on 10 off Mashrafe. Umpire Ian Gould did not hesitate for a moment to shake his head in favour of Raina who walked across and exposed his leg-stump at the moment of impact. In naked eyes and in a flash of a moment the left-handed seemed plumb in front, however, DRS revealed the ball pitched fractionally outside leg and did not matter whether it was hitting the stumps or not. On any other day, Gould would have given that out with Raina not having a doubt about it.
The second instance was more unbelievable. Rohit, on 90, was caught at deep midwicket off Rubel Hossain dipping full-toss but Pakistani Aleem Dar (standing at square-leg) to shocked everyone by calling it a “no-ball.” Replays clearly showed the ball was well below the waistline, but for some weird reason in this era of technology, Dar and Gould did not find it necessary to seek help from the third umpire over their walkie-talkie! Rohit left adding 47 more runs.
“That should have been a wicket. The ball was under the waist,” cried out Shane Warne at the commentary box. “He (Aleem Dar) has lost his confidence,” added the Australian spin legend.
Former India batsman VVS Laxman meanwhile criticised Gould and tweeted, “Bad decision from Gould, was definitely not above the waist. Lucky break for Rohit. This can be the difference in getting extra 20 runs.”
The official Cricket Australia Facebook page ran an opinion poll asking for thoughts on umpires Aleem Dar and Ian Gould’s “no-ball” decision. For obvious reasons majority of the comments came from the Australians among which Andrew Ritter wrote, “Two terrible decisions now. The lbw was millimetres from being out, and it was not a no-ball.”
A Saud Jan said, “This is the 2nd one. Before that it was judged as pitching outside leg. It was pitching in line and crashing the stumps. All the decisions will go India’s way, that is for sure. For Big 3, cricket is not a sport, it is a business dominated by India.”
Another fan, possibly from Bangladesh, Apon Rahman provided a new idea and suggested ICC to introduce “touch detection boundary rope” and “height detection meter.”



