Never in the history of ODI cricket has there been such a disastrous start of an innings like Pakistan’s in their fixture against the West Indies. Having lost their opening matches, both teams needed to win this encounter. While the Caribbean lot’s presence was evident, Pakistan never showed up to play.
I am sure there is a raucous discussion going on all across the cricketing world; more so in Pakistan than anywhere else. However, the fact of the matter is Pakistan is a team that has been in disarray even before the tournament started. Even with Mohammed Hafeez in the team, they got thrashed in both matches of their two match ODI series against New Zealand in January. In the warm up matches, they should have and would have been beaten by Bangladesh had it not been for Bangladesh’s inability to add another 25 to 30 runs to their total, which they were in a position to do so.
Pakistani hopes for any success rests on a few individuals who must deliver. First and foremost, Shahid Afridi must strike with the ball as must Mohammed Irfan. So far both have failed. I have always stated that Afridi is a good bowler and a part time batsman. In the past Pakistan has won matches more because of his ability to take wickets at crucial times. His batting, if it came along, was a bonus. If you expect him to bat at No 7 or 8 and depend on him to win matches, then Pakistan’s batting is in trouble. In addition to Afridi, the top order like any other team has to produce runs. Pakistan has been struggling for years with its batting. The only reason they have been able to compete at this level is due to the resilience and consistency of Misbah-ul Huq. He has produced more runs for the team than a few of its batters put together.
Leaving aside the failure of its players, the cricket world is absolutely dumbfounded and finds the minds of the Pakistani selectors a total mystery. Younis Khan has made immense contribution to Pakistan cricket and to willfully allow him to be embarrassed on the world stage is the unkindest cut of all. If one did not know his cricketing background and saw him for the first time in this World Cup, one would take him to be a total misfit. Younis, like all great players, must have the common sense to know when his time is over. He should have stepped out of the scene on his own. Younis is good for another year or two but only for Test match cricket played at home (UAE/sub-continent conditions).
Repeated reliance on Umar Akmal to keep wickets is abysmally bizarre. His performance is like a broken record with the needle getting stuck in the dropped catch column. If Pakistan takes him for this batting, then they should develop him into an opener where the team has had consistent problems.
In a crucial match against the West Indies, they went into the match with a part time bowler as the 5th bowler in Haris Sohail. The irony of it all is that he could have ended up with 3 or more wickets in the match had Akmal and Afridi not dropped two vital catches off his bowling. Pakistan needed to have someone like Yasir Shah in the game. His performance against India in which he got knocked around for 60 runs should not have been the yardstick to measure his ability. The Indians are some of the best players of spin bowling and they were prepared for Yasir. Remember, Afridi also failed to take any wicket against India and he too got milked for 50 runs. I feel that Yasir should be a regular in the side. So far the Pakistan bowling, other than Wahab Riaz, has lacked the venom it once had. Irfan is physically unfit. His giant like physique is more a selling point for the media than anything else. With his frequent follow through problems, which pushes him into the danger zone, he is forced to bowl within certain limitations. Added to the bowling inefficiency is the horrific fielding performance that turned out to be a comedy of errors. This must have been the worst and, probably will be, the worst fielding performance by a team in the 2105 World Cup. The way Afridi flinched when he dropped a chance at short square leg is ample evidence that age is catching up on him.
Pakistan’s batting is another story. Two words describe it best - spineless and shambolic! Starting with Ahmed Shehzad, not one of its batters moved their feet to come behind the ball. When a player is not moving his feet into the line of the ball, it is proof of his nervousness and his lack of courage. The Pakistanis players had frozen legs. The same attack was painlessly and efficiently taken to task by the Irish batsmen who chased 300 plus and won. Compare that innings with that of Pakistan’s. The difference in class is easily noticeable.
Pakistan plays two teams that will not only give them a hard time but will play to win. Both Zimbabwe and Ireland are playing terrific cricket. I am not bothering to mention the match against South Africa for obvious reasons. If Pakistan goes down to Zimbabwe in their next outing, then there is good chance that it may end up exiting in the first round. In Pakistan, mock coffins have already started appearing in public in several towns.
Yousuf Rahman (Babu), former national cricketer, vice captain and first centurion writes from New York for Bangladesh fans all across the globe.



