Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Should Tendulkar retire?

Update : 27 May 2013, 05:10 PM

Sachin Tendulkar announced his retirement from the IPL recently. Last year, the veteran called quits on his ODI career – in which he scored 18,000+ runs and 49 hundreds, figures that may never be eclipsed. What remains for India’s most famous cricketer?

In 1989 when he debuted, Tendulkar represented a new generation of cricketer; those who valued shorter forms of the game just as much as classic Test cricket. Today, 24 years later, Tests are all he has left.

He stands atop the list of leading run-scorers and century makers at this highest level, and perhaps it is his determination to ensure he remains there that keeps him going. Though apt to underplay the significance of records publicly, one suspects that they mean something to Tendulkar.

Calls have been made for him to make way for a younger man. Some have called him selfish for holding back a new generation of players. With Laxman, Dravid and now apparently also Sehwag put out to pasture, why not Tendulkar, who has averaged 24.46 in his last 10 Test matches? What can a player who has scored so on the flat Indian wickets, possibly do in South Africa against the best pace attack in the world? Should he retire? Should he be dropped?

The reality is, Tendulkar is as good a batsman as there has ever been, and his future is in his hands. He is, of course, now at the age of 40, not the player he used to be, but that is irrelevant. The selectors do not have the choice of replacing him with a younger Tendulkar. The critical question is – is there a better player to take his place now?

In foreign conditions at least, one suspects no. Many Indians play fluently and well in the subcontinent but are turned inside out when the ball swings, cuts and rises in England, Australia or South Africa. Tendulkar can still take such conditions in stride, probably better than anyone in the side, and India need him for that reason.

Tendulkar’s troubles have largely been self created. The years have slowed his reactions, but unlike Sehwag, he has the technique to compensate. It would require an adjustment in style and he would not be as exciting to watch, but the runs on the board should still come.

He does not have it in him anymore to play even slightly across the line of the ball. At his best, it was his stock shot, an angled bat glide to take a single or two on the leg side. It is a shot most players can play without undue risk, and used to it as he is, Tendulkar continues to try to play it. He misses far too often, and frequently gets out to the shot.

When Dravid failed in Australia, he was being bowled through the gate while playing straight. He simply could not get the bat down in time, and that was a sure sign that his time was up. Tendulkar, by contrast, has been getting out bowled and LBW while playing across the ball and missing. If he plays straight, he might not get runs from the shot, but he would not get out, either.

The choice is Tendulkar’s. A change in style that would turn him into a unglamorous player – like Dravid or Kallis – but an effective one, for there are no obvious physical weaknesses to exploit, or carry on with the sweeps and angled bat glides that his eyes just are not up to?

Should he adjust, Sachin Tendulkar, 40, and with the eagle eye gone, still has the potential to be a big run scorer who can play any type of attack in any conditions.

Top Brokers