Ten apparent strangers journey to an estranged mountain where their host has set up an intricately designed death trap. One by one, they all must die to pay for their sins. The only chance of survival is through identifying and eliminating the killer.
Inspired by Agatha Christie’s 1939 novel “And Then There Were None,” Impress Telefilm’s latest instalment, “Kaler Putul,” wasn’t its most impressive work. However, it deserves to be noticed for authenticity. Director Aka Reza Ghalib knew what genre he and a whole generation of “Kishor Thriller” readers liked. He went for it in a leap of faith, undaunted and unprepared.
His humbleness spills over onto the screen and we can’t help but feel deep respect for that. It was an honest case of “we didn’t have enough filmmaking training available, but we have stories we need to tell” and that honesty and humility is very refreshing.
“Kaler Putul” doesn’t proclaim to be a blockbuster or a crowd pleaser. It was targeted towards a niche audience who love adventure movies so much that they’re willing to look past its obvious flaws.
The film was shot in a beautiful location in the hill tracts where the winter fog augmented a sense of mystery. The elaborate set pieces -the hanging bridge and the bungalow – resembled those in timeless adventure stories.
One might expect a number of overlooked details in the work of a debutant director. In the case of “Kaler Putul,” the two indefensible oversights were in its screenwriting and acting departments.
The dialogue was overdone, and a lot of scenes needed to be cut short. For instance, it took the actors over ten minutes just to drive and walk to the bungalow in the beginning of the movie. All the while, the ten guests were talking without any notable progression in plot or character.
The movie admittedly took inspiration from Agatha Christie and Alfred Hitchcock, but there were other not-credited inspirations. The chevron floor, the red curtains, the dwarf with a funny voice – were unmistakable references to the black lodge in “Twin Peaks.”
When Shahed Ali’s character compared their situation to a book he once read, it was a missed opportunity to inject bits and pieces of information about how the characters in the book die, so we fear for their lives when they’re trapped in similar circumstances.
Some of the dialogue needed some explanation to be logical. For instance: After caretaker Kennedy’s murder, Raisul Islam Asad says: “Ami khuni na hole ki shomoshsha jano? Porer jon je khun hobe sheta ami howar shombhabona onek bariye dey (Do you know what the dilemma is if I’m not the killer? It raises the chances of me being the next target much higher.)” He doesn’t go on to explain how his chances are higher among the ten guests.
One of the reasons why we don’t feel empathy for the characters is because we know they’re all murderers, yet they don’t possess many redeeming qualities. For instance: while Moon’s character’s abusive boyfriend drags her in front of everyone after a song ends as abruptly as it started, no one protests, as if they’re all devoid of compassion.
Some of the actors did a great job shining in an ensemble cast - notably Raisul Islam Asad and Bithi Rani Sarkar. However, the newer actors needed to give much more solid performances, which damaged the movie a great deal. As for Ferdous and Ashish Khandakar, as captivating as they are, it seemed like they were in two different films. Their acting styles were too far apart.
The first half of “Kaler Putul” is so loosely knit that it takes conscious effort to stick around to find out who the killer is in the end. Nevertheless, if this is the product of a first draft, I’m rather excited to see what Reza Ghalib can bring to the screen next with a properly polished script.
The writer is a screenwriting graduate from UCLA and has worked in Hollywood in film development. She is a member of the International Federation of Film Critics.



