Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

They know what they are doing, right?

Update : 22 Apr 2015, 06:33 PM

A string of recent news stories is painting a dismal picture of life amid the heat and dust of Dhaka:

1) The horrible assaults on women at the Pohela Boishakh/Bengali New Year celebrations and the inaction by security agencies to arrest the culprits 

 2) The alleged attack on the cavalcade of the opposition leader while out campaigning -- her lot were just as bad during the cruel days of Hawa Bhaban, but that’s no excuse  

3) Much of the compensation money not being paid to Rana Plaza victims, according to Transparency International  

4) Self-imposed exile to Toronto by fearful social media satirists 

5) Murders of bloggers and inaction by a regime keen on “securing secular support via occasional executions of yesterday’s war criminals” while leaving today’s bloggers vulnerable to street executions.

Here’s what could have happened instead:

1) The TSC thugs arrested despite any perceived political links (though even better would be for the police to morph from passive spectator to active security-enforcer)

2) Free movement for all political candidates with no threatening rent-a-mob chanting during the mayoral campaign (and still the favoured Annisul Huq gets to win?) 

3) Garments victims fully paid up and government undertakings to workers (and businessmen) fulfilled -- think about stability of electricity/gas/law and order and subsidised food for workers to offset low margins from greedy foreign buyers, etc 

4) A government, confident of its unassailable political position, allows for “digital dissent” among the young urban minority -- who, by the way, rarely take to the streets. This would otherwise be called “smart politics” 

5) Courage to take on terror networks who commit such shocking public executions. After all, the strength of a state is when it alone has the monopoly of violence ... so, inaction can be taken as a sign of weakness, get it? 

After the mayoral fuss is all over (you don’t really believe the position has much more than symbolic power, do you?), the real battle with the BNP will commence. 

Unless there is an unexpected (unlikely but certainly not impossible) public backlash via the ballot box, the plan seems to be to enact the final decapitation of the main opposition forces, replacement by friendly toothless outfits, and thereby the establishment of a permanent Party hegemony, “democratically achieved,” modelled perhaps on the Nehru dynasty in the first few decades of post-1947 India ... 

But, as they say, the best-laid plans ...   

A penchant for scoring own goals

Given the backdrop of global economic instability and almost permanent war in large swathes of the Middle East and Africa, the story from Bangladesh is refreshingly optimistic. Or it could have been. 

Just imagine if the regime had pulled out all the stops to support garments entrepreneurs with bold policy action and implementing past promises while standing shoulder-to-shoulder with its garments workers, ensuring prompt compensation payments, meting out justice against any criminal owners, and providing subsidised support for workers struggling with spiralling food and housing costs in Dhaka. 

Imagine if they had sacked the advisers who had decided that the Chittagong Hill Tracts should become a semi-No-Go area. Just because Delhi mistreats its citizens in Assam and Nagaland, it should not mean we need to follow suit. We can do better. 

Can you imagine if the government decided to finally implement the Hill Tracts Accords which it signed back in 1997? From this high moral ground, it could then provide a robust defence of the rights of Rohingya refugees. 

By allowing for digital dissent, with the chance of suffering an occasional inconsequential insult or two, it could earn the support of much of the dharma-niropekkho public (those whose politics see religion as neutral). 

That would rise manifold if they showed zero-tolerance to street executioners. 

By providing sensible answers to questions about disappearances of opposition leaders and activists, (and ensuring it does not happen again) it could once and for all reject the charges of a creeping Baksalisation which opponents are so ready to throw against it. 

Framing an alternate story

All these are a distraction from what could be a positive story of economic progress and widening prosperity. We know the fruits of growth are barely trickling down as inflation eats into nominal rises in wages but the country is coming to a critical stage. 

Does it finally jettison the 1970s with its agenda of war crimes, one-party government, and threats of military coups? Can it shift the debate onto creating a national consensus on how new industries can rise? Don’t we have to reduce our vulnerability in relying on a low-technology-low-cost-low-margin garments industry?

From eggs in one basket, the urgent issue should be how to procure more baskets and diversify even while supporting that one basket to reach $50bn in annual revenues.

Young people, the middle-aged intelligentsia, and long-term investors could help create this consensus via social media, print media, TV talk-shows, and public face-to-face discussions. Democracy is more than an occasional mark on a sometimes-rigged ballot paper. It also means listening to people’s concerns, hopes, and ideas. That makes it participatory. 

But before entering that bright-eyed barely believable world of alternate reality, people must first see justice for crimes committed against women celebrating New Year, for crimes against bloggers, and for crimes committed against the poor industrial workforce.

Some of that same dogged determination to go hell-for-leather against war-criminals would not go amiss in seeking redress for injustices in 21st century Bangladesh. 

Can you recall a time in any era of post-liberation electoral democracy where the opposition has been so weak, fractured, and devoid of ideas or direction?

From this position of strength, could wiser heads within the elite not demand a final drawing of a line over 1971 and replacing that ageing agenda with a new debate about creating a consensus of a brighter future that moves from PR slogans to a believable narrative … 

Maybe, the regime can afford to disregard these thousand words as they do so many million more. An all-seeing, all-knowing regime can plough on regardless. Like us, it can also create its own understanding of what constitutes reality.

That is fine as long it does not confuse cunning with intelligence. Short-term repression for long-term survivability. Knee-jerk reactions for thought-through strategy. 

But why concern ourselves with their thought processes? Should we not retain our faith in them ensuring this does not end up as their political tragedy? Of course we must. They know what they are doing, right? 

Top Brokers