The universal appeal of democratic consensus can be hard to argue against. In a world where unanimity is impossible due to free thought, the next best thing, logically, is allowing the majority to make decisions. On paper, it sounds good enough. In reality, it is a tyrannical concept made worse by its alleged value.
Majority rule -- or, more specifically, keeping the majority happy -- is the mandate being used to suppress the rights of large portions of the global population. It is the excuse bandied about when persecuting religious minorities in the Middle East.
This includes the campaign by terrorist organisation IS to kill Christians in Iraq and the legislation by the legitamised regime in Saudi Arabia to kill atheists. It is the same logic applied by Buddhist extremists in Myanmar in their relentless campaign against the Rohingya Muslims.
Securing and preserving democratic consensus is why LGBTQ+ individuals are still considered criminals in most of the world’s countries and why legislation like the Indiana Right to Discriminate Bill can pass in places where they are, nominally, citizens with equal rights.
Since they represent a minority of the population, their voices are always drowned out by the majority. This is why Indian Penal Code Section 377 was reinstated in 2012. Even in cases where minorities are allowed to have a say, such as the upcoming equal marriage referendum in Ireland, there is the obvious risk of them being overruled by sheer force of numbers.
Particularly problematic is consolidating minority rights that might go against the accepted religious and social norms of the majority, even if these rights do not actually infringe on anyone’s way of life. In these cases, the ideal solution would be not to interfere, but the integrity of majority sentiments is likelier to overrule minority freedoms than not. Such is the reality of democratising rights.
As it is, true democracy and accountability do not exist even in the most watertight political system. When this flawed concept is then applied to rights, it is not only problematic, it is downright immoral. Rights, by definition, should be universal and unquestionable. Minority rights, in particular, need to be protected by these principles because they affect disadvantaged groups.
Yet, majority rule has always been used to deny them equal treatment. Part of the movement against women’s suffrage was based on framing the female population as a minority. Black civil rights movements were similarly stalled on the notion of disrupting the way of life for the many for the benefit of the few.
Legally, these notions should have no leg to stand on. This is why some judiciaries can be expected to uphold pro-minority rulings. Section 377 had been repealed by a Delhi High Court after all, before popular demand brought it back. The same can be said of the 2010 Bangladesh Supreme Court ruling against the fifth amendment to the constitution, effectively reinstating secularism but not really put in practice.
Even in the West, that bastion of democracy, it has been a rejection of majority consensus that has led to greater respect for minority rights. Anti-LGBTQ+ laws like Prop 8 were voted in by referenda but eventually overturned by legal means, though that has not stopped other laws from being proposed for future ballots.
Slovenia recently ruled that any rights-based laws cannot be voted on as that goes against the spirit of universality. Unfortunately, this type of sense is very rare in the world.
As evidenced by the ineffectiveness of most judicial rulings, the entrenchment of democratic decision-making in the way society thinks means there needs to be a fundamental shift in the way people view rights and, indeed, democracy itself. Simply being part of a larger group should not give anyone a larger say. If that is how rights continue to operate, they can no longer legitimately be called so.



