Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Why was HRW out to save Kamaruzzaman?

Update : 11 Apr 2015, 06:08 PM

The Supreme Court on Monday rejected Jamaat-e-Islami leader Muhammad Kamaruzzaman’s review petition challenging his death penalty, and he was executed late Saturday night.

New York-based Human Rights Watch had asked the government to suspend the execution and demanded that Bangladesh impose an immediate moratorium on the death penalty, which it terms barbaric, pointing out that many countries have abolished the death penalty.

However, the rights body, surprisingly, did not give any statement against the execution of Azizul Huq Bachchu at Kashimpur jail on Monday night. Bachchu was given capital punishment for stabbing to death two sisters in 2005 at Borai village of Natore. The sentence was upheld by the High Court and the Appellate Division. The president rejected Bachchu’s mercy petition on March 4.

The charge against Bachchu was proved and therefore his sentence executed. On the other hand, it is also proven that Kamaruzzaman committed crimes against humanity during the 1971 Liberation War. He was behind mass murders at Sohagpur village of Sherpur’s Nalitabari, which is now dubbed as the village of widows.

Why was HRW so concerned about Kamaruzzaman’s execution, but not Bachchu’s?

According to its policy, HRW is against the death penalty. They think it is the highest level of violation of human rights. However, in the statement issued on Tuesday, the organisation did not mention that they had protested Kamaruzzaman’s execution because of their stance against the death penalty, but claimed that the trial was flawed, and demanded an independent review suspending the execution.

“Bangladesh’s war crimes trials have been plagued by persistent and credible allegations of fair trial violations that require impartial judicial review,” HRW Asia Director Brad Adams said in the statement. There were no further elaborations about the flaws or how justice had been violated. Nonetheless, Adams urged the government to suspend the execution without presenting any evidence.

The sentence did not come after a summary trial. It took five years for the International Crimes Tribunal, established in line with Bangladesh’s constitution, to complete the trial. It is an open court. All the rules, including appeals, review, and presidential clemency have been applied in this case. The due process of law was fully exhausted. However, HRW remains dissatisfied with the trial and the consequent sentence.

Curiously, HRW appears to rally behind only the war criminals of Bangladesh sentenced to death. Their stance is not against death penalty in principle but only apparently if it is given to a war criminal. And each time, they have labelled the trial process “flawed and questionable.”

The New York-based rights organisation was also vocal before the execution of Kamaruzzaman’s counterpart in Jamaat, another assistant secretary general of the party, Abdul Quader Molla, who was hanged on December 12, 2013. They campaigned across the world to stop Molla’s execution.

Earlier the HRW was issued contempt of court notice for making similar remarks in the war crimes case against Jamaat guru Ghulam Azam in 2013. The HRW later apologised and was pardoned. But that did not deter it from issuing similar statements.

The desperation shows HRW’s apparent willingness to risk their reputation and goodwill just to come out in favour of the Jamaat war criminals.

The death penalty is still in use in 32 out of 50 states of the US. In 2014, there was not a single execution in Bangladesh, but there were 35 in the US.

The United States of America, where the Human Rights Watch is based, is fourth in the number of executions in the world according to the UK-based Amnesty International. US is the only country that still uses such execution methods as gas chamber, firing squad, and lethal injection.

The HRW has failed to stop these in its own country. They keep mum about these executions but are actively expressing concern over the execution of war criminals here in Bangladesh. Only a handful of people are executed here. Why didn’t HRW stop those 35 executions -- a more serious violation of human rights?

Moratorium on the death penalty was withdrawn in the US through court in 1976. The HRW was formed two years later. Why have they failed to stop executions in the last 40 years? 63% of Americans support the death sentence. Since 1976, a total of 1,389 executions have taken place.

Do as we say, not as we do. As per its policy, the HRW does not make public the names of individuals and organisations that finance their activities. The announcement regarding the policy is found on its website.

Why can’t they ensure transparency of their own funds although they raise questions about the standard and transparency of the trial of war criminals?

We know that Jamaat has already spent millions of dollars to stop the war crimes trials; their efforts are still continuing. They even appointed lobbyists.

Is it possible that part of the Jamaat money has gone to HRW too? It is merely a question that comes naturally out of curiosity, given their strange affinity towards Jamaat leaders. It is up to the HRW to ensure transparency by disclosing information about their funds now.

Top Brokers