Defying all predictions to the contrary, Israel’s hawkish prime minister has a fourth-time chance to be at the helm of his country’s government, albeit his party won only a fourth of the parliamentary seats.
If he runs the full next term, he will be the longest serving prime minister of Israel after David Ben-Gurion. Political analysts both in the US and in Israel attribute this last minute rebound of Bibi (as Netanyahu is known) in a tightly fought contest to latest public statements opposing statehood to Palestine, stoking of Israeli fear of a nuclear Iran, and his brazen calls to his supporters to counter Israeli-Arabs’ voting strength (they consist 20% of voting population in Israel).
And Netanyahu’s victory follows closely on the heels of his open criticism of the Obama administration’s negotiations with Iran on a nuclear deal. He did not stop by voicing his opposition from his country; he also carried the message all the way to Washington and vented his opposition to any such deal in a joint session of the US Congress.
With a razor thin margin of victory over his nearest opposition, Netanyahu may not represent the wishes of all Israeli voters. But in a parliamentary system that allows formation of government by the single largest party with support from like-minded factions, Israel will pursue policies that Netanyahu and his party choose.
And these policies will not necessarily be favouring those that Obama and his administration would like to see in the Middle East. Here is the rub.
Obama and Netanyahu had a tense relationship from the time the former became president of the United States. Unlike his predecessor, Obama came to office with a more pacific worldview, one that promised withdrawal of forces from Iraq, drawing down on military responses to quell international disputes, and a renewed effort to mitigate Israeli-Palestine hostilities eventually leading to a two-state solution. Not that Obama succeeded in his foreign policy goals, for many of the goals were stymied by several uprisings and new wars in the Middle East.
A country’s foreign policy is not always dictated by the wishes or choices of its head of state, definitely not the United States. In the US, the actors come from many stages, the Congress, the political parties, and other pressure groups.
Notably, the pressure groups come from a wide spectrum of politics, corporate interests, lobbies, and the so-called think-tanks. Among foreign countries that have a stake in US foreign policy, Israel is at the forefront, and no other foreign leader knows better than Netanyahu how to play these different actors.
His biggest success in this effort was his invitation by the US Senate to address the joint session early March, where he chastised US negotiations with Iran, calling them harmful. He also used the podium to court voters in his own country, and apparently he succeeded.
It will be an overstatement to say that a Netanyahu victory will pose a stumbling road block for Obama to further his Middle East policy, in particular, his ongoing nuclear deal with Iran.
There are many more imponderables in furthering Obama’s objectives; the opposition from a Republican-dominated Congress being not the least. Obama’ foreign policy has been faulted by his opposition on many counts, including his apparent choice against military intervention in Syria and Ukraine.
His latest efforts to reach a nuclear deal with Iran (alongside five other Western powers) on conditional lifting of economic sanctions against Iran, subject to Iran’s restriction on nuclear energy uses, have been denounced by the hawks in the country. But even then, a renewed term for Netanyahu means continuation of a fierce opposition to Obama’s overtures to Iran with a substantial domestic support.
Will Obama’s foreign policy objectives in the Middle East falter, given the prospects of mounting opposition to it home and abroad? Will he shy away from a nuclear deal with Iran, or will his administration give up the hopes of future Israeli-Palestinian negotiations for a peace deal?
Obama has less than two years in office, with no prospects of another term. Netanyahu has four more years. His hopes will be to see any Obama initiatives to fail, and even if they succeed now, these will not be sustained in a future US presidency from the opposite party. For Obama, his success will be if he can pull through his current efforts.
Of the two, the nuclear deal will perhaps go ahead if Iran sticks to its own end of the bargain. The deal may not hold later if a Republican wins the presidency next time, but for now, Obama may see through this despite an unfriendly Congress.
The Israeli-Palestinian deal for now and the foreseeable future will probably be shelved. The Middle East, in the meantime, will continue to boil in the cauldron.



