Ever since Sureshbhai Patel was assaulted by the police in Alabama, there has been a lot of outrage in the government and media circles of the Indian Union, and correctly so. This 57-year-old man from the village, Pij, in Gujarat’s Kheda district, was visiting his prematurely born grandson, born to his son who had gone to the US to study engineering and is now a US citizen.
The police confronted Sureshbhai as he was walking on the footpath in his son’s neighbourhood and for a brief period, grilled him in English, a language that Sureshbhai didn’t know. Then he was brutally attacked, resulting in him being bloodied and paralysed due to severe spinal injuries. How ridiculous is it that simply not knowing a language can make one unsafe and vulnerable to this extent?
It was a weird feeling learning about that, because I had just flown from Bengal to Nagaland in a flight mostly filled with Bengalis and Nagas – in a flight that had no safety instruction, announcement, signage, or reading material in Bengali or Nagamese.
In the US, Sureshbhai didn’t know the language of Alabama and was in danger. In Kolkata airport, most CISF personnel don’t know Bengali. In Chennai’s main railway stations, most RPF personnel don’t know Tamil. In the Indian Union, the central government airlines and railways do not care about the mother-tongue of a section of its customers and puts people’s lives in danger on a daily basis. Why?
Many brown people of the Indian Union have been protesting American police brutality and racism with extra vigour this time – one way to get back at the communal harmony tips that President Obama has been giving to brownland.
The US certainly has a pathetic record on this count. Mostly white police typically patrol mostly non-white areas, to assault and arrest mostly non-white people, who are then tried in courts full of mostly white judges.
But change colour/race to caste/religion, and the previous sentence does not seem to be true only for distant US and hits uncomfortably closer to home. In this subcontinent as a whole, one solution that has often been advocated in the US, is to ensure that security is entrusted with locals, so that the force is racially representative and socio-culturally literate about the context in which it operates.
If we cut to the subcontinent, a radically opposite picture arises. Here, the security apparatus carries forward the British colonial policy where ethnic insurgents from one area (say Nagaland) are typically dealt with by sarkari armed forces that hail mostly from another area (say Bihar and UP) to ensure “peace and prosperity.”
The same goes for the Punjabis in Balochistan, the Pathan in East Bengal, and Bangladeshis in Jumma territories. Why is it always the case that most of the security forces deployed in Nagaland don’t know any Naga dialect, those deployed in Chhattisgarh don’t know Gondi, those in Manipur don’t know Meitei, those in Rangamati don’t know the language of Chakmas.
Is this purely accidental? Is a lack of mutual understanding between combatants, between armed forces and the people, a pre-condition for ensuring smooth and efficient security operations? What does “smooth and efficient” or for that matter “security” mean in such cases? What’s going on here in our name? Why do they fear making local language literacy a pre-condition for deployment of forces?
Sections of the audio excerpt from Sureshbhai’s attack communication log haunts me. One policeman asks: “Do you understand?” Another policeman says: “I don’t know what his problem is, but he won’t listen.”
While the Alabama police should be held accountable, the communication between police personnel in audio form and even a video of the confrontation and attack on Sureshbhai is on public record. If brown people in the US are dealt with this level of transparency, can we not expect at least that amount of transparency from brown policemen in brownland?
There is no security without compassion. There is no security without empathy. There is no security without legitimacy in the eyes of the people being purportedly “secured.” All acts that lack these qualities when done in the name of security are sins in the eyes of the gods, even if some “holy cow” paper document says otherwise.



