Time for a pop quiz.
A newspaper publishes a picture of a poster put up by the banned extremist organization Hizb-ut Tahrir in an apparent attempt to foment unrest in the armed forces, under the heading: Fanatics raise their ugly heads again.
Below the picture, the caption reads:
“Taking advantage of the current political crisis in the country accompanied by wanton violence, banned extremist Islamist organisation Hizb-ut-Tahrir published and pasted posters in the capital in an attempt to foment unrest within the armed forces. This poster was found pasted on a wall in an alleyway near Bangla Motor intersection yesterday.”
What would you conclude was the intent of the newspaper and what would your response or reaction be?
(a) You would conclude that the newspaper had done a good job of informing you of a troubling development, and your reaction would be to hope that the government would take notice of this renewed threat.
(b) You would conclude that the newspaper has done a good job of passing on this stirring call to arms, and your reaction would be to waste no time in preparing yourself for the coming uprising against the tyranny of the state.
(c) You would conclude that the newspaper was in bed with HuT and was trying to stealthily advance its agenda under the guise of reporting the news, and your reaction would be to promise severe action against the offending newspaper and its editors.
If you answered (a), congratulations, you have passed elementary reading comprehension and responded in a logical and reasonable manner, as one would hope from a conscientious citizen.
If you answered (b), not only is your reading comprehension in need of remedial help, but you also may wish to find some new and better friends.
If you answered (c), congratulations, you are the prime minister of Bangladesh.
Please note that answering (c) means that you must believe that a not inconsiderable number of people answered (b).
I think that almost everyone who gives the question a fair-minded reading would answer (a) and that almost no one would answer (b). And if no one would answer (b), then it is clear that (c) is the wrong answer, too.
Except, of course, this isn’t just an academic exercise. The offending poster was in fact pasted all around Dhaka city on the night of February 10 and its picture was published on page 3 of The Daily Star the following day.
Not only has this resulted in a case being filed against the newspaper’s editor, chief news editor, and chief photographer, but the prime minister has helpfully weighed in, offering her opinion that “the paper has helped the radical cause” and promising stern action against the newspaper (to a chorus of sycophantic cheers in parliament).
Does anyone else (and I mean only those people who actually have their own opinion and cannot reliably be counted on to agree with anything the PM says) really believe that the Daily Star was attempting to stir up trouble by publishing this news item and picture?
Isn’t it clear that precisely the opposite is true, that the newspaper was trying to do what is its job to do: Namely to inform the public? Is this not an issue of public concern? Does the public not have a right to know that this kind of subversive activity is taking place? Is the offending poster not a matter of public interest?
And does anyone really believe that by publishing the picture, the newspaper advanced the agenda of the outlawed outfit and its supporters?
Section 505 of the Penal Code, under which the case has been brought, makes clear:
“Whoever makes, publishes, or circulates any statement, rumour, or report, with intent to cause, or which is likely to cause, any officer, soldier, sailor, or airman in the Army, Navy, or Air Force of Bangladesh to mutiny or otherwise disregard or fail in his duty as such ... shall be punished with imprisonment which may extend to seven years, or with fine, or with both.
It does not amount to an offence, within the meaning of this section, when the person making, publishing, or circulating any such statement, rumour, or report, has reasonable grounds for believing that such statement, rumour, or report is true and makes, publishes, or circulates it without any such intent as aforesaid.”
Was the picture published with any such intent or is there any such likelihood of such a reaction to its publication? To ask the question is to answer it.
The government has enough real enemies and enough real crime to deal with without having to manufacture imaginary ones.
What next? The government has already made it clear that it is unhappy with the way the media has covered the current crisis the country is going through. Next, perhaps it will be telling us what is acceptable to say about the crisis and what is not.
The government complains bitterly and constantly that the media is not foursquare behind it in its fight against terrorism. It is constantly telling the media that we should be on their side, and that to remain neutral in the current situation is to be a party to the terror.
But you can’t complain that you don’t get a fair shake from the media and question why they are not on your side at the same time as you are showering them with abuse and accusing them of being fifth columnists who are no better than the terrorists.



