Even Tiresias the blind was not as handicapped by his loss of vision as we politicians seem to be today in this proud nation of ours. The goddess Athena, overcome by pity or remorse, gave the hapless Tiresias the gift of augury, but we have had no such luck; our blindness has been further exacerbated by rage and envy. Many of us, especially my brothers and counterparts in the Awami League and the BNP, have so entrenched themselves in a state of internecine war that they’ve lost sight of the actual goal of serving the polity.
There seems to be no way out of the impasse, and all of this is due to the intransigence of just two leaders. The practice of democratic politics, or the political process that is acceptable in a democracy, has come to an end; what reigns in its stead is war in the guise of politics. All stakeholders seem to be confounded with the nation’s plight. The rush to appeal to the two leaders has reached a fever pitch, but the response from the prime minister remains cold and severe.
In a democracy, the political process is based on dialogue, but in the absence of such, how can we expect to pull ourselves out of this mire?
The prime minister is adamant that no dialogue can start with people associated with “terrorist” activities. Notwithstanding the accuracy of the label, should the nation be held hostage just because two people cannot see eye to eye? Is the problem really as intractable as it seems?
From where I stand, I don’t see the problem as intractable at all. Of course we have two sets of problems, one short-term – the current hartals and concomitant violence; the other long-term – political accountability.
In the scamper for dialogue, we seem to have forgotten that the BNP actually wants an election, so any dialogue will be dialogue about an election. However, the election has to come under a non-partisan government, vis-à-vis a free and fair election. When the next election is to be held is of no consequence, what matters is the system under which it will be held and for it to be fair. Give them that and there should be no more commotion, and more importantly, give them that and there is no moral legitimacy left in their movement, and as history has taught us, no movement can or will continue without an iota of moral legitimacy.
We can argue then, that instilling confidence in an electoral system and ensuring free and fair elections in general will go a long way in dispelling this current crisis.
We need to stop treating our national politics as a zero-sum game of electoral spoils between two factions (parties) and start creating the basis of a lasting institutional democracy. We can only achieve that through ensuring transparency and accountability for all, and therein comes the need to uphold the sanctity of institutions.
I take a two-pronged approach to this: Constitutional amendments and institutional independence. While we all swear by our constitution, we care little to accommodate the realities of our age in that sacred document. A two-third majority is required to amend the constitution, and with Article 70, which prohibits any MP from refraining from voting or voting against party lines, any party holding a two-third majority can change that most sacred political document willy-nilly.
All accountability of individual MPs is simply eroded and the citizenry can’t truly hold their chosen candidate culpable when laws are passed that make a mockery of governance and justice.
There are more constitutional issues that need attention, including closer scrutiny of the powers of the president and the prime minister and creating a definitive space and thwarting interdependence between the two. Separating political parties from their parliamentary counterparts is also something that needs further attention. These are all important issues that need more discussion and expert analysis to resolve.
On the other end, the institutions that ensure accountability and stable governance are many, but the ones that need immediate attention for our polity could be identified as (a) election commission, (b) the judiciary, and (c) law enforcement. The election commission has the onus of holding free and fair elections, and hence is responsible for establishing accountability in the electoral process – that which the BNP, and for that matter every other political party, demands.
An independent and empowered election commission is a minimum requirement for credible elections, and examples abound on the success of independent commissions the world over. But even after a credible election, the conduct of every player in the political process needs overseeing, and the judiciary is the institution that provides the rules of the game and, as one of the three pillars of democracy, holds the executive and the parliament in check. It isn’t the parliament that ensures the sanctity of the constitution, it is the judiciary.
Last in this list, but by no means the least, is law enforcement. Starting from police to RAB and all in between, these institutions are empowered to uphold the rules of the game and thus ensure accountability. Faith in the actions of these institutions has to be absolute in order for any polity to function smoothly.
So, how do we make these institutions more robust? We separate them completely from the political process. We give these institutions independence from political interference and give them the finances and the necessary powers to fulfil their statutory obligations. Of course, even these things are a little more complex than how they appear on paper, and there’s much more minutiae than meets the eye, but they are not only possible, but indispensable if we are to have a stable polity for the foreseeable future.
In conclusion, I appeal to the current government and our honourable prime minister to take the initiative and give this land the democracy that we deserve. The Jatiya Party has vowed to give this country just that kind of good governance, and if the current government fails the people, then the Jatiya Party will not. But we do not want the people to suffer an instant longer than they must, and I pray that the prime minister will not let us down.



