Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

George W Hasina

We are far too aware of how the fear of terrorism can be whipped up into an excuse to conduct witch-hunts 

Update : 06 Aug 2024, 01:24 AM

We’ve heard it all before.

The rhetoric being peddled by the government and its boosters in the pro-government media is now more or less indistinguishable from that put out by the Bush administration and parroted on Fox News in the aftermath of 9/11.

We see the same chest-thumping and bellicose posturing that used to be a staple of US political discourse, the same moral preening, the same bullying line of argument, as each ruling party leader vies to outdo the others in appearing tough on terror and uncompromising in the face of terrorist atrocities.

We see the same denigration of anyone who offers any but the most simplistic of good versus evil, black and white narratives of the current crisis, or suggests any kind of introspection on the part of the government, or counsels any form of compromise or dialog.

They are just as bad as the terrorists, we are told.

Indeed, let me hasten to make clear at this point that I completely, utterly, and unequivocally condemn terrorism and the targeting of innocent civilians, and let me reaffirm that there can never be any justification for such atrocities.

Just so there is no confusion, you understand?

You see, if I do not preface anything I wish to say about the current political situation with a pithy denunciation of terrorism, then I run the risk of being seen as a terrorist sympathiser, if not an abettor, if not an instigator.

To repeat: I am against torching buses and burning people to death. Please make no mistake on this point.

Unfortunately for the government, this kind of George W Bush: “You are either with us or you are with the terrorists” argument is finding few takers in Bangladesh. The truth is that when Bush originally tried to stake out such a position, it found few takers here then, either, and in a sense inoculated Bangladeshis against such an argument.

The problem that the AL government faces is that the War on Terror, as articulated by George W Bush in 2001, never gained any rhetorical traction in the Muslim world, and that to try and apply its logic in a country like Bangladesh is bound to run into skepticism if not outright mockery.

In the first place, we are far too aware of how the fear of terrorism can be whipped up into an excuse to conduct witch-hunts against one’s enemies, both real and imaginary, and to justify the most appallingly repressive measures in the name of counter-terrorism.

We are also aware that the moral difference between those who commit acts of terror and the state terrorism that arises in response to it is not as wide and clear-cut as the authorities would like us to believe, and that there exists a murky under-belly to every anti-terror agenda that is in many ways almost as sinister as the force it professes to counter.

We are also well aware that while nothing can justify the targeting of innocents, that it is nonetheless foolish not to try to comprehend the root cause of such atrocities or to try to pretend that past and present injustice is in no way connected to terror.

No one justifies flying planes into buildings and killing 3,000 innocent people, but by the same token, the argument that US foreign policy was a contributory factor to the atrocity of 9/11 is something that is acknowledged by the more thoughtful commentators in the West and by virtually everyone in Bangladesh.

No one justifies the human rights abuses of the so-called Islamic State or believes that anyone is ultimately responsible for their reprehensible actions other than those who commit them, but by the same token, it is also true to state that had there been no second Gulf War, the world would have likely been spared the horrors of IS.

In short, the existence of the Islamic State is the fault of George W Bush, and everybody knows it.

If he hadn’t invaded Iraq, they wouldn’t be there today. Recognising this does not in any way minimise Islamic State culpability and responsibility for their atrocities, but it does provide necessary context and suggest that it is fair to be blamed for the foreseeable consequences of your actions and policies.

There is such a thing as blowback. We understand this very well when we look at the War on Terror in a global context. Actions have consequences. It is a basic and universal moral principle that we can and must hold parties responsible for the consequences of their actions.

This does not mean that George W Bush is as guilty as Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi for Islamic State crimes against humanity. Not even close. But it does mean that he is not entirely guiltless, either.

Now that the War on Terror has been imported to our door-step, the government should not be surprised when trotting out warmed-over War on Terror rhetoric is met with indifference and cynicism by the Bangladeshi public. Nor is it right for the government to take such skepticism to suggest that the population is on the side of the terrorists.

Berating the public for insufficient moral fortitude in the face of the ongoing carnage, or suggesting that those who are not convinced, either by the government’s rhetoric or its tactics, are part of the problem, is simply not a winning argument in the Bangladeshi political context.

You are not going to win the hearts and minds of the people by identifying with a mind-set and spouting rhetoric that has long ago been discredited in the eyes of the Bangladeshi public. 

Top Brokers