What a difference a year makes.
When Dhaka Tribune ran an opinion poll in the immediate aftermath of the January 5, 2014 election, the results were unequivocal.
A year ago, 73% wanted fresh elections as soon as possible, 63% favoured a caretaker government to oversee elections, and competitive elections would have been too close to call, with the difference between AL and BNP less than one percentage point, well within the poll’s margin of error.
Fast forward to the most recent DT poll on one year of the new government, and it is clear that the AL gambit to push through one-sided elections has paid off in spades.
The number of people calling for fresh elections before the end of this government’s tenure is down to 49% (although, interestingly, this number was lower in the DT poll held six months ago). However, less than 10% of those polled felt that holding early elections should be the government’s top priority.
Meanwhile, the poll revealed broad satisfaction among the general population for the government’s first year in office.
Over 70% of those polled rate the government’s overall performance as successful. When we broke down the question sector-wise, the lowest positive rating was for law and order, but even there 62% rated the government as successful.
Twenty-three percent opined that the government had had no major failures in its first year in office.
Conversely, over 62% of those polled rated the BNP as being unsuccessful. This number was 52% when DT asked the question 6 months ago, suggesting dissatisfaction with the BNP is growing.
When it comes to each party’s share of the popular vote things also seem to have changed over the past year.
When asked whom they would vote for if elections were held today, AL polled 41% to 34% for BNP.
The long and the short of it seems to be that the AL has gotten away with its one-sided elections.
In a DT poll conducted on the eve of the election, fully 77% opined that elections without the BNP would be unacceptable, closely matching the number wanting a re-poll right after the election.
But now with the AL government in place and no path to bring about fresh elections (whether under a neutral government or not) apparent, the public appears to have accepted the government as a fait accompli.
As they say, possession is nine-tenths of the law.
No one even brings up the AL’s bait and switch maneuver to win support for the January 5 elections, where they argued that the elections were a constitutional necessity and that once they were done that negotiations for a fresh, fully competitive election could take place.
No sooner had the elections taken place, then the party backed away from this pre-election pledge, with, as we have seen, no apparent consequences whatsoever.
The only good news for the BNP in the recent poll was that the AL lead among voters was a scant 3% in rural areas (compared to 22% in urban areas) and that in the 18-24 demographic, it actually out-polled the AL significantly, by 48% to 34%, suggesting that the long-term prognosis for the party may be more positive.
However, the BNP may wish to consider the fact that Khaleda’s approval ratings seem to have taken a nose-dive, with 48% to 22% preferring Hasina to her as the next prime minister.
Similarly, a salutary lesson should be drawn from the scant support shown for Khaleda’s son, Tarique Rahman, the party’s senior vice-chairman and heir apparent.
That said, if you parse the poll carefully, it is by no means the undiluted good news for the AL that casual observers have taken it to be.
The crucial take-away seems to me to be that while people have been reasonably satisfied with the new AL government’s first year in office, support for the party is neither deep nor strong.
The fact that fully 34% say they would vote for BNP despite the fact that 62% express dissatisfaction with the party suggests to me that the AL’s current popularity remains tenuous.
The numbers suggest that even a modicum of competence and vision on the part of the BNP would be sufficient to shift popular opinion in their direction, and that support for the AL is based to a large extent on the failures of the BNP.
The fact that BNP outpolls AL by 48% to 34% among the young generation, despite the party’s shortcomings, is also very striking, and should give pause to both parties.
The younger demographic rated the BNP performance higher and the AL performance lower than other age groups, but not by much.
Among 18-24 year-olds, 68% still believe AL has been successful in its first year in office and 58% still believe BNP has been unsuccessful.
What does it mean that they would therefore plump for BNP over AL by 14 points?
Perhaps satisfaction with the AL is not as clear cut as would appear at first glance.
Zafar Sobhan is the Editor, Dhaka Tribune.



