Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Who will they save today?

Update : 05 Jan 2015, 06:04 PM

We live in a subcontinent where the ideas of home and roots are being constantly challenged by a minority who look upon these things as a hindrance to their upward mobility and lifestyle choices.

They are being able to mount a challenge because of their disproportionate over-representation among the rich, the powerful, the Anglophone and the connected – all of which amount to their casting a long shadow in the world of urban opinion-making and general policy.

Like most shadows, the size of the shadow of this class is very different from their actual size, which is still miniscule. However, they increasingly dominate in setting the goal-posts of aspiration and are able to talk down to the rooted majority without having a stake in anything. That translates into having a superficial stake in everything. Let’s start with tigers.

It wasn’t too long ago that tigers became all the rage, especially in media. Everyone wanted to save tigers. Of course, everyone comes with the caveat of being a sliver of society at most, but that is a continuing bane of the Anglophone in brown land.

That is a boon for the rest of the browns, but that is another matter. Anyways, much tears, warmth, newsprint area and airtime was devoted to the tiger and its preservation. The principal habitat of the tiger in the subcontinent is the Sundarbans, a mangrove forested deltaic territory criss-crossed by countless rivers and water-channels before they empty out into the Bay of Bengal. 

The territorial administration of the Sundarbans is divided between the West Bengal state of the Indian Union, and the People’s Republic of Bangladesh. In all this love of tigers, how much do the people and locale and cultures and life and the feel of the Sundarbans figure?

Apparently, not much. Because, on December 9, 2014, there was a huge oil-spill at the Sela river of Sundarbans. This released 350,000 litres of oil into the downstream rivers and water channels and everything that is connected to them, touched by them, lives in them, on them, by them, and dependent on them.

But alas, there is little sympathy or even awareness on the most part among the very vocal and public save-the-tiger-wallahs, including their sponsors, promoters, wheeler-dealers, suddenly-discovered experts, activists, Facebook cover-photo changers and others.

Members of the species who had become one with the tiger, have moved on to another issue, another saving act, another bout of rootless global awareness. In the meantime, those in the Sundarbans also know it by another name – it’s called home. They don’t exactly explore the exotic, nor do they describe themselves using that pathetically vacuous giveaway called interested in other cultures.

The Sundarbans of “Save the Tigers” origin is a make-believe idea that was the flavour of the week in the make-believe world of the self-certified righteous Anglophone brown ones. Elite rootlessness has its advantages.

But there is something more to it. It has to do with the spatial-ideological location of things that mostly populate their minds. When the BP oil-spill happened near Florida, there were squeaks of concern from this class.

When I used to live in Boston, a small-town by subcontinent standards, a city-wide chase for two young suspected terrorists happened. This spawned a lot of solidarity with Boston. This is the brown class that is now riled up about racist police violence against black people in the United States (Eric Garner #icantbreathe).

This is the same class that is interested in an armed hostage-taking crisis in Australia and the Muslim-friendly concerns of a section of the resident population (Sydney #illridewithyou). Very worthwhile human causes indeed. But there are other humans too. Much nearer to “home.”

Every brown city has had shoot-outs and brown people killed for various reasons, this day, this week, this month, this year. In this cold winter in Delhi, more than 30 slum homes were demolished in Wazirpur of Delhi. Remember Golibar?

But all that is too close for comfort. Online is one thing, but this real. They even have to march. As friend Uday Chandra bitingly puts it: ‘‘Are we really going to march with our servants? We can’t even kiss them and they don’t get our jokes in English.”

Even in cybersphere, with only so much bandwidth, what one chooses to engage with, is a political choice. There is another aspect. Consumers of long-distance solidarity things are typically out of depth when they step out into the real brown world with the browns they become exasperated – except when they talk to ones belonging to the nodding, clicking, liking set.

The group that has breathing problems after going online and accompanies other people in rides also wanted to save the tiger, once upon a time. With the social-image builder function being served, what stake is there, beyond appreciating the aesthetics of protest art, if it can be called so? Can they breathe? With whom did they ride today? 

Top Brokers