Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Poll position

Update : 05 Sep 2014, 08:01 AM

My phone has been ringing off the hook since Monday when the Dhaka Tribune published its opinion poll on the government’s first six months in office.

In response to the first question I am asked, let me state unequivocally that I stand fully behind the poll. The poll was conducted by IRC, a well-reputed polling and research firm, along precisely the same lines as the previous two Dhaka Tribune polls. 

Our last two polls have held up well, corresponding closely to other polls commissioned contemporaneously, and seemingly being confirmed by subsequent observable facts on the ground, and I am confident that the polling methodology employed in all three polls has been sound and scientific, and that the results are very credible.

In response to the second question as to how could the poll results show the government so popular when everyone knows the opposite is true, I would humbly submit that it is precisely because we do not know, beyond our own limited circles (that may or may not be representative of the nation as a whole), how people are thinking, that it is important to conduct polls in the first place.

Anecdote, casual conversation, unscientific observation, and dime-store analysis are simply no substitute for the empirical process of polling to try to get to the heart of public sentiment and perception.

Are polls infallible? By no means. Can they be wrong or inaccurate? Most certainly. 

But I think it is important to understand the science behind polling and to accept their results as a base-line from which to conduct one’s analysis. 

Now, it is possible that the DT poll was what is known as an outlier and did not fully capture or present an accurate picture of what the public thinks. It is for this reason that I welcome more polling by other organisations.

The more polls we have, the more accurate the picture we will receive, and this information can be very useful to us in terms of crafting or assessing public policy and spotting important trends, or shifts in the public mood.

I also think that it is equally important to know how to parse the information that a poll reveals, and to understand what it actually says and does not say. To my mind, a careful reading of the DT poll suggests results that are not nearly as unexpected or far reaching as would appear at first glance.

Let’s take the almost 70% of the public, who feel that the country is now heading in the right direction, compared to roughly an equal percentage who felt the opposite when we polled them in December 2013.

Well, why is that so hard to fathom? The country then was mired in shocking political violence and appeared to be on the brink of civil war or at least a never-ending cycle of bloodshed. No one knew whether the Jan 5 election would even be able to be held or what the aftermath might be. 

Fast forward six months, and things are a lot better. The streets are safer, there appears to be some measure of stability, the economy appears to be chugging along, and the uncertainty and violence of the last six months of 2013 appear to be a thing of the past.

Similarly, while immediately after the Jan 5 elections, fully 77% wanted to see new elections within one year, is it so hard to believe that, after six months of relative peace and quiet, a majority might now be content to let the government see out its term?

Nor is the 75% satisfied with the government’s performance in its first six months so hard to credit. Look back to the opinion polls from 2009. The Bangladeshi public (indeed this is true almost everywhere in the world) is generally charitable to newly-elected governments, and it typically takes a while for disenchantment to set in. There is even a term for it among political analysts: The honeymoon period.

So, none of these results are particularly outlandish or inexplicable. But the important point is that neither should they necessarily be interpreted as a strong endorsement of the government or a strong statement of support for its conduct.

That’s not what I read in the DT poll results. What the poll suggested to me is a populace that is sick and tired of violence and instability, and is enjoying a little peace and quiet. More than anything else they simply want to get on with their lives without having to worry about the buses they travel in being burned or the schools their children go to being shut down or the businesses they own or patronise being reduced to rubble.

Frankly, had the BNP taken part in the Jan 5 election and had they won and come to power, we might well be seeing the same results in reverse. 

The importance of the DT poll is that it points us in the direction of the right questions to ask: What do these poll results mean in terms of what the Bangladeshi public wants, and what are the implications for the future of the Bangladeshi polity?

I don’t have the answers, but sometimes knowing the right question to ask is almost as important.

Top Brokers