Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Out of your league

Update : 21 Jun 2014, 06:50 PM

Now that the fireworks have ended, the stars have gone home and people have moved on to other sports, it is probably a good time to talk about certain things. The richest “team” in the Indian Premier League (IPL) T20 cricket tournament won. Kolkata Knight Riders (KKR) is also the IPL franchise that has generated the maximum profit.

This franchise represents Kolkata at the IPL. In a subcontinent that abounds with self-appointed thikadars, from neighbourhood to religion, KKR has received the thikdadari of the brand called Kolkata. Let us not mix up that private brand with the very public urban agglomeration, the capital city of West Bengal, which goes by the name Kolkata. Inhabitants of Bengal typically don’t prefer red chillies with their rice, but green ones. Such thikadaris have also been given for brands named Chennai, Delhi, Mumbai, Hyderabad, etc.

KKR won the tournament and Rs15cr in prize money. Just after this was announced, an unverifiable Internet meme went viral. It claimed that Shahrukh Khan had donated Rs15cr for cancer-care in Kolkata and Mumbai. Like most internet memes, this nugget of benevolence could not be verified. The most verifiable and substantial thing that connects the city of Kolkata with the branded franchise Kolkata Knight Riders is the stupendous amount on unpaid taxes that the owners of KKR owe to the Kolkata Municipal Corporation (KMC).

KMC’s deputy mayor let out the simple mathematical truth – KKR had not paid Rs1.16cr in taxes owed from the last three years, as of May 20, 2014. This just goes to show that at the end of the day, the owners of KKR are running a business. And if the business strategy involves not paying taxes, so be it. Incidentally, the tax money that KMC collects is used to clean and maintain sewers, run health centres, maintain roads, and provide drinking water to the thousands in Kolkata who were cheer for the knights of the Shahrukh order.

So much for the periodic “love” for Kolkata and its people that is declared by the KKR and its owners. If I owed someone more than a crore and that person cheered me instead of pressuring me for payment, I would love him. I would dance for him, wherever, whenever, for free. If he had something to sell, I would promote it for free. There must be “something different” about any place where I am publicly felicitated when I actually owe huge amount of tax money to it.

With things so alien like a Corinthian helmet being the emblem of a bunch of “knights” in the land of lethels (lathi-warriors), it is not surprising that the closest thing to Kolkata that figured in the T20 final was Shakib Al Hasan. At a time when talk of illegal Bangladeshis is doing the rounds in imperial metropolis of Delhi, the legal Bangladeshi in the KKR team in the form of Shakib Al Hasan was the saving grace for Kolkata and Suba Bangla.

I wonder how this IPL thing is received in the cricket-loving quarters who revel in thrashing people for supporting foreign teams. If it is not anti-Kolkata or anti-West Bengal to recruit alien players for a team built by a private entity (KKR), how does a supporting or not supporting a team built by another private entity (BCCI’s Team India) become some test of loyalty, citizenship, tricolour and all that?

Or conversely, if it is about “swadeshi,” then supporting the team with even more ethnic and cultural consonance with one’s “desh” is better, I suppose. There should be no problem if some West Bengalis start supporting the cricket team from Bangladesh against the BCCI team that has few if any Bengalis. Or say Gurkhas of the Indian Union supporting Nepal in a football match with the Indian Union. What makes one private entity using a nation-state (India) as a brand more authentic in any way than KKR that uses the name of a city (Kolkata) that is older than the nation-state of India?

In the meantime, the media bombardment will ensure cheerleading from metro-based “Bongs” for “their” side – the charming thing that is post-1990 market deregulation driven “Bong” pride. It is domesticated enough to only do korbo, lorbo in front of their TV sets.

In the People’s Republic of Bangladesh, the presence of any kind of IPL phenomenon is rather unfortunate. Internationalism is all good, but the sad bit is that it is the poorer and the darker peoples of the world who always have to prove their internationalism by opening up to phenomenon elsewhere.

That some Bengalis in the East are excited about a private commercial project like IPL that is funded primarily by Indian banias and executed by mercenary sportspersons underlines the triumph of corporate globalisation. It generates in its clientele an inferiority complex as well as a pathway to be included in the happening global class. The empire wants the periphery to the extent that in generates revenue. Make no mistake. Bangladesh generates revenue for IPL in more than one ways.

How consciousness gets fashioned, how prototypes are created, how some newer loyalties are celebrated and some older loyalties are conveniently forgotten – all this is the stuff of collective myth-making and how power casts its long shadow on the people. Kolkata’s KKR is in many ways similar to the British Indian Army. Fighting ostensibly in the name of cheering, happy brown people, the owner is a distant king man whose god on earth status has been constructed.

And yes, the browns foot the bill of the battles, the revelry and all that. They always have. There is a more sinister element to this, especially for us Bengalis. During the Second World War, Britain deliberately caused the death of 3 million people in Bengal by starving its populace so that its imperial war effort could be well fed. None of the people who served in the British Indian Army during the Second World War, remaining loyal throughout to a man-eating boss called Britannia, lost their job.

The long-range result of that level of Anglophilia, continuity and alienation is rather clear. When todays Bengalis remember genocide in the Second World War, they remember Jews, gays, and Gypsies. 3 million hapless Bengalis don’t find a place in that list. Zainul Abedin, Chittaprosad Bhattacharya and many others chronicled those millions that Britain murdered. But today’s Manchester United fan from Dhaka has not heard about Chittaprosad, the Chelsea fan from Kolkata has not heard about Zainul. These are signs of dangerous times – of a slowly progressing ice age, starting from the tropics.

Top Brokers