Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

A media monster

Update : 18 Jun 2014, 07:12 PM

Media activism is an issue which warrants more debate. As the dust of the long multi-phased Lok Sabha election settles down, it is time to have a critical look at the role Indian media has played in the run-up to this crucial election.

This recent Indian election appeared to be no less melodramatic than a Bollywood masala movie. And it unmistakably picked the recent Bollywood trend of making the anti-hero a hero, regardless of some gesture of moderation. The disguised director of the movie seemed to be the Indian media, almost collectively. And the producer was supposedly corporate India with a subtle understanding with the directorship.

It is unprecedented that the national media of a democracy in this age has taken up a scheme that is way outside of their natural purview. Yet it has happened. The result is – initially unexpected – a resounding victory for the BJP. Of course, there were other factors, but implicit assistance from the media, in general, is what has helped the political outfit to attain the crucial extra mileage that has taken them past the magic figure on its own – the first time for a single party since 1984. It may also spell a paradigmatic shift in Indian politics, ie reverting to a single dominant party system from the coalition culture of the last two decades.

If one had observed this carefully, he or she would have noticed the way Indian media has been setting up agendas in the run-up to this 16th Lok Sabha election. On the one hand, it completely ignored the relative economic success of the UPA-2 government under the adverse global trends. On the other, it blew out of proportion limited achievements of one person – Narendra Modi – in order to promote him as the saviour of the nation in a perceived dire situation.

All this brings forth the question: How does the media set agendas, news, or discussion topics? Why is it averse to comparative, in many senses, sector-wise objective talks? And why did it make the persona of one controversial politician the point of persistent focus, eventually drawing, by and large, positive conclusions about him despite records to the contrary.

Day after day, it was basically Congress and the Gandhi family-bashing in one way or the other in most of the influential English, Hindi, and many other regional press and electronic media. At the opposite end, there had been an extensive craftily drawn exercise of projecting Modi as the wizard of development, which is of course, a claim not sufficiently substantiated. The media also took up a largely revisionist take at his role as the chief minister in not deliberately saving the Muslims in the Gujarat riots in 2002.

It’s true that the Congress has shifted economic policy wisely from investment and growth-oriented to pro-poor “trickle down” policies and social security leniency. Perhaps the party wanted to create a stable political base beyond just caste and community dynamics. But as it somewhat contradicts the interest of corporate India and the well-to-do upper caste middle class , the latter are now all out to haunt the grand old party.

The upper caste well-offs have been the traditional and stable support base for the BJP. They dominate the sophisticated domains like corporate India, media, and intelligentsia. Now there is a silent agreement to see the decade-long UPA off. Despite most of the recent pre-election opinion polls going wrong, TV channels and newspapers are doing it again and unequivocally spelling the doomsday for Congress. This self-fulfilling prophesy has worked for the goal the Indian media has set for this election.

Again, even if one is not as cynical, there are alternative explanations of media pro-activism in Indian politics. As the polity of the country is getting more and more fractured with every passing day, and the party system has degenerated to coalitions which are now faltering as well, the media in India has perhaps tried to resist further decay and save a functional coalition system. 

As per the media mind, a hung parliament could have spelt disaster for India, hence at least a replacing coalition led by a major national political party is preferable. Indian media perhaps fancied a German-like two coalition system to maintain political order in their diverse agglomeration. The rational course for them is – as the Congress-led UPA is likely to do bad in the election, they should be made to do the worst and as the most prospective replacing coalition, the BJP-led NDA, may do well, they should do the best. But the outcome was even better than what they envisaged.

That’s fair enough, in a way. But did this lead to democracy? How does media activism play out with democratic propriety and true representation of people? Are the electorates aware of this implied media clout? Can they take decisions fairly either assimilating or ignoring the media feeds? From where can they get objective information and analysis? These are difficult questions with no easy answers. This could also be true, fully or partly, for many other democracies.

It’s true that Indian media has almost forced Modi and the BJP to moderate to a certain extent. It’s not clear though, whether this overt change is genuine or just symbolic. There will be, for sure, media pressure on Modi and the BJP to maintain this moderate development-focused posture. But given their past record, what unfolds is anybody’s guess.

The danger is that if the BJP fails to deliver on the promises which aren’t easy with the kind of overblown expectation they have created, then they may well try to revert to hard Hindutva for their political survival.  Will the Indian media be able to reign in the Frankenstein’s monster it has created when the monster starts reasserting its primitive propensity? This could be the biggest question for the future of media pro-activism in the Indian election or in any other watershed moment. 

Top Brokers