Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Money across the border

Update : 17 Jun 2014, 06:33 PM

There have recently been a couple of references in this and other media outlets in the region, and on social media, about a recent report by an Indian organisation (Silicon India) that listed Bangladesh as the fifth largest source of inward remittances into India, with around 500,000 workers contributing $3.7bn.

In the telling and re-telling of this tale in various media outlets in the region, there appears to have been little or no additional analysis of these numbers, and all these workers have been assumed to be illegal migrants taking away jobs from the local population.

It is obviously a tempting statistic to use to counter India’s Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s election campaign statements regarding illegal migrants from Bangladesh into neighbouring Indian states. 

The goal of this article is not to debate those statements, but rather to examine the implications of the quoted numbers of Indian workers in Bangladesh a little more closely. The conclusions one arrives at are: a) The numbers are likely to be inaccurate, or b) if they are correct, then the impact is actually quite beneficial to the Bangladeshi economy.

I have the luxury of writing this from the picturesque hill station of Coonoor in the state of Tamil Nadu in South India, away from the summer heat of the plains, the tumult, the noise, and the distractions of a big city.

As a result, tasks like simple arithmetic become a lot easier. If we divide $3.7bn by 500,000 (workers), we arrive at an average remittance figure of $7,400 per person.

Presumably this is an annual statistic, although this is not explicitly clear from the quoted article. Let’s assume that each worker, on average, sends half of his or her annual earnings home to India (a not unreasonable assumption). By this estimate, his or her monthly income computes to around $1,200.

In other words, each of these alleged illegal Indian workers in Bangladesh is earning Tk90,000 a month! By comparison, the average worker in a garments factory floor now makes around Tk5,000 a month, thanks to salary hikes recently authorised by the government.

Who do you know who makes Tk90,000 a month? Or even Tk55,000 a month (the number that one would arrive at if one assumed an 80% conversion rate of salary into remittances)? I’m willing to bet they’re not  unskilled jobs of the kind normally taken by illegal immigrants in any country. More specifically, it is highly unlikely that the majority of these alleged 500,000 Indian workers in Bangladesh are taking away garment worker jobs from locals. The math just doesn’t compute, although I’m perfectly happy to hear what others might have to say to dispute my armchair and its findings.

The more logical conclusion of course is that, if the numbers are accurate, then these workers are in higher wage jobs, where local expertise is likely lacking. And rather than being a drain on the Bangladeshi economy, they are obviously positively contributing to it like skilled labour anywhere, by generating benefits to their employers to justify paying them a middle to upper-middle class salary by Bangladeshi standards.

Middle class spending anywhere is a key engine of the economy, and if these workers sent 50% or $3.7bn home, then they also spent that much on goods and services within Bangladesh.

Hopefully I’ve made my point! But let us assume for argument’s sake that these 500,000 Indians are in fact illegally in the country. Let us track them down in their Gulshan and Banani hideaways and send them home (which will free up housing stock for Dhaka’s own upwardly mobile population). Let us confront them as they sip their scotches behind the walls of the International Club and serve them notice that their time here is up. What next?

Who will replace all those skilled workers until enough local talent is available? Where will they come from?

Very simple. Bangladesh doesn’t need anyone from anywhere else. You have enough sons and daughters all over the world who have, to use the cliché, done their country proud, in fields ranging from the arts and sciences to finance to academia.

And who have the potential to effect long-lasting positive change in the country of their origins. During my two years in Bangladesh, I met several inspiring individuals who had done just that, and taken the leap of returning home. It obviously won’t be easy.

Here in India, for every person I know who has come home and is making a positive difference, I know another who gave up in frustration, and went back. So, what will it take for the others who have done well abroad to come home?

It doesn’t have to be forever. A lot can be done with, for example, a three or four-year commitment. But you won’t know till you try. And you’ll never regret having tried. And most importantly, each Bangladeshi who brings home their skills or expertise with a larger purpose than just their careers and/or personal gain in mind will inspire a thousand others in a way that none of those 500,000 Indians and other foreigners can. 

Top Brokers