That image of a lone unarmed protestor standing defiantly before a column of tanks is firmly secure in the collection of iconic 20th century images. It speaks volumes – not just of the courage of the individual but of faith in something which triggers superhuman actions from seemingly average people. Supermen in real life never possess extraordinary powers – they just rise above the human level to aspire to something special.
In 1989, when the Tiananmen incident unfolded, China was still cloaked in mystery. It was an enigma which, at the fag-end of the cold war, was firmly tucked away behind a thick curtain of communism. The country was a far cry from modern day China where communism is the shiny red cover for a large box filled with the mouthwatering trappings of capitalism.
As we all know, the student-led democracy movement was crushed by the government, much to the dismay of the West and as the 25th year of the rising is being commemorated, there is once more a buzz around the event – obviously, used more as a propaganda machine to discredit the Chinese government.
The campaign to revive the Tiananmen is gearing more pace as China becomes assertive in territorial disputes, sending out feelings of chill among its neighbours. From a neutral perspective, suppression of any popular movement, especially if it involves killing, is condemnable but if we look at the evolution of the country post 1989 and assess its rise as an independent nation which has delicately created a balance between capitalism and communism, we find that the government that quelled the uprising learnt a tough lesson. In fact, they not only learnt a lesson but also decided to carry out subtle changes which have turned China into an intriguing paradox of sorts – a glamorous hub of consumer luxuries with the hammer and sickle intact on top.
Maybe this rather perplexing blend was never envisaged by China’s detractors. In fact, if someone had floated the idea in the early 90s that China would soon undergo phenomenal changes while holding to the basics of her ideology, very few would have given credence to it. Surely, the comforts of the West cannot be introduced by keeping the communist core intact? Amazingly, that is exactly what has happened.
If I understand the policy right, the government made concessions – gave the citizens everything they wanted, encouraged private-sector growth, and even turned a blind eye when items deemed for too long as signs of Western decadence flooded the country. Would anyone have believed in the early 90s that BMW, Aston Martin, and Ferrari would find the best markets in China?
There was one condition though – do whatever you want, pursue whatever your heart desires, but leave the ruling to the selected party members. Twenty five years later, is seems, the plan has worked to the letter. Yes, rampant corruption is a concern but China has recently surpassed Japan as an economic giant.
Recent reports say that young Chinese are not too familiar with the episode 25 years ago and the government has erased most records of it. Such moves to cleanse history has been criticised by the West as a move to crush any chance of free thought. Interestingly, no one in the West ever talks about the highly dubious British-French intervention in Egypt in the 50s and nor does anyone refer to the selfish politics to topple democratic governments (Iran in ’53, Chile in ’73) during the cold war period. To recall declassified historical documents, some did not want to recognise or condemn the genocide being carried out in Bangladesh in 1971.
Also, when imperial powers talk about their history, they carefully sideline events of the past where blatant gunboat diplomacy was used to subdue others. Going back in time, China was turned into a massive opium market with several European nations setting up fortifications. When the Chinese rose against dismemberment of the country by imperial powers in what is called the Boxer Rebellion, a joint military force was sent by almost all major Western powers under the banner “Eight-Nation Alliance” to subdue the uprising. This adventure was glorified in the 1963 movie – 55 days at Peking.
After victory, massive suppression followed. Officials who supported the rising were executed, plus a large indemnity of silver was imposed on China. If China is wary of the West and any movement that reeks of Western ideologies, then they can’t be blamed, because the 100 years of humiliation – the period when she was controlled by outsiders – is etched deeply within the nation’s identity.
Of course, at the same time, one cannot condone the killings of protesters and the subsequent crackdown on dissidents simply on the grounds that in any country, citizens have the right to express their feelings openly. For argument’s sake, let’s look at a hypothetical scenario – China, faced with widespread protests, decides to carry reforms and the old administrative order is scrapped. If the 1989 episode had succeeded, would we have a China with a robust global voice or would we be facing a mollified country willing to kowtow to others?
If there is any lesson to learn from the so-called democratic movements in the Arab world which the West endorsed effusively – no revolution brings an abrupt end to old problems, they just compound already existing anomalies. Having said all that, the audacious rise of civilians in China won’t be forgotten because if that event didn’t take place, the authority in the country would not have triggered the process to change the once monolithic outlook.
So in a way, Tiananmen was not a failure. It was a wake-up call which the administration took seriously. Hence, the modern-day economic miracle plus a formidable military might happen. After all, if all countries are pacified, there won’t be check and balance. The world cannot have one-sided-superiority, it needs a counter balance.
As Newton said: Every action has an equal and opposite reaction. So for the 100 years of forced subjugation plus mindless injecting of opium for profit, there has to be some reaction.



