Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

A request too soon

Update : 05 Jun 2014, 07:03 PM

During her recent visit to Japan, Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina sought assistance for six mega projects which includes a nuclear power plant.

In response, Japan’s Prime Minister Shinzo Abe said: “Tokyo and Dhaka would begin expert-level dialogue on the peaceful utilisation of nuclear power in Bangladesh to share the experience and lessons learned from the Fukushima Daiichi power plant incident.”

Though highly satisfied with the outcome of Sheikh Hasina’s visit, particularly in getting assurances of loan and economic aid worth $5.9bn over the next four years, our delegation must have been disappointed on this polite but cool response from Prime Minister Abe. Honestly, I did not expect more than what he offered. It is probable that our prime minister was not correctly advised before seeking Japanese assistance for a nuclear plant. Her advisers simply did not do their homework properly.

Japan had a severe nuclear accident at its Fukushima Daiichi Nuclear Power Plant in 2011. The cost of damages for the nuclear accident is estimated to be $300bn. Because of the strong anti-nuclear sentiments of the Japanese people, the government had to shut down all the operating nuclear power plants in the country. It is uncertain when the plants will be restarted, if ever. Even if the plants are put under operation again, it will cost approximately $700m to $1bn per unit for building tsunami defences and incorporating other modifications to satisfy regulatory requirements following the Fukushima incident. To make up for the loss of electricity generated by the nuclear plants, Japan’s import bill for fossil fuel jumped by $40bn per year and the average cost of generation of electricity increased by 56%.

If the nuclear power plants are not put into operation soon, most of the utilities, including Tepco which owns the Fukushima nuclear plant, will be under severe financial constraints failing to repay the bank loans they took for the construction of the nuclear plants which ceased to earn any revenue since being shut down. Tepco may even go bankrupt, if not rescued by the government.

Japan’s Hitachi, Toshiba, and Mitsubishi have associations with USA’s General Electric and Westinghouse, and France’s Areba for building nuclear power plants abroad. In most cases, the Japanese companies supply the conventional parts of the plants (turbines, generators, etc) whereas their western partners provide the nuclear islands (steam generating systems). Japan has not built any nuclear power plants abroad even though they have plans to do so in Turkey, UAE, and UK.

According to a report by the World Nuclear Association: “Following the Fukushima accident, reactor manufacturers are reported to be finding it difficult to do business abroad because Tepco, the main operator partner, is preoccupied with remediation at Fukushima.” Japan’s nuclear industry being preoccupied with the decommissioning of damaged and retired nuclear power plants and implementing design modifications in the existing plants for the improvement of safety, it was most unlikely that they would venture to build a new nuclear power plant in Bangladesh. As a matter of fact, the nuclear industry in Japan is in disarray at the moment, and the government is in a difficult situation coping with the aftermath of the Fukushima nuclear incident.

It may be recalled that the Chernobyl incident in the former Soviet Union, now in Ukraine, cost an estimated $100bn, and indirect costs for damages may accumulate to over $200bn for Ukraine. It took more than a decade for the Russian nuclear industry to recover from the shock of the nuclear disaster and regain full potential for the construction of new nuclear power plants at home and abroad.  

Japan too needs time to recover from their nuclear accident. We cannot blame them for the cool response to our request. We were naïve to raise the issue at this stage and embarrass a trusted friend for no reason. 

Top Brokers