Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

The largest democratic event on Earth

Update : 11 Apr 2014, 07:31 PM

Finally, Mamata Banerjee, chief minister of West Bengal, had to comply with the Election Commission’s order and remove seven officials from their existing posts and replace them as desired by the poll panel. Earlier, she was adamant. “I challenge the Election Commission to remove anybody while I am in charge,” she declared. “How can the Election Commission transfer and name new officers without consulting the state government?” asked the chief minister. Banerjee promised she would “not remove a single officer” and was ready to face the consequences.

Perhaps Mamata had no other option. She knew her challenge would bear no fruit. There was every possibility of a postponement or cancellation of the polls if she didn’t comply. The Indian EC has demonstrated once again that it has the upper hand in the administration during the poll period.

In February 2012, union law minister Salman Khurshid was obliged to apologise to the EC for violating the code of conduct by promising a 9% sub quota to the minorities in Uttar Pradesh. Dr SY Quraishi was then the chief election commissioner of India.

I read the news of Mamata’s compliance with great interest after having attended a presentation by Dr SY Quraishi at the CIRDAP auditorium on March 24 on “India’s General Elections – 2014.” He cited many instances to show how he managed to transfer several influential government officials as there were allegations of partiality against them.

I was, therefore, very curious to know the outcome of the challenge by Mamata Banerjee. I am now convinced that what we heard from Dr Quraishi about the authority of the Indian Election Commission is not fiction but absolutely true.

Before the presentation, I was introduced to Dr Quraishi by Mr Sujit Ghosh, counsellor of the Indian High Commission in Dhaka. I thus got an opportunity for an informal discussion with Dr Quraishi. He was very amiable and receptive. Our discussion centred on the caretaker government and neutrality of the Election Commission. He said: “There is no need for a caretaker government if you have a strong and independent Election Commission.”

According to him, the government has virtually no function as far as the election is concerned, and “the Election Commission assumes absolute supremacy over the administration during the polls.” I asked him if he ever faced any criticism about the neutrality of the Election Commission by any political party. He emphatically said, “No, as far as I remember.”

Dr Quraishi spoke for about an hour and later answered questions. He cited several interesting incidents to show how the Indian Election Commission exercises its powers and maintains neutrality. In one incident, he forced an incumbent chief minister to pay for the plane fare of his entourage from his own pocket as he flew to New Delhi to discuss with the commission about the election date in the state.

By the way, his request was also not accepted. He added that even “the Indian prime minister knows the schedule only at the last moment.” In another incident, the chief secretary, the police chief, and the home secretary of a state, were removed simultaneously as they appeared to be biased to a party.

India conducted 15 parliamentary elections, and more than 340 general elections, to state assemblies, while more than 3 million representatives were elected in the national, state assembly elections and local bodies’ polls after the country had chosen democracy in 1950, Dr Quraishi told the audience.

He said the use of money power was a major concern, but the EC devised ways to enforce a stringent vigil on election expenditures to minimise such practices. He said the opposition parties, the mass media, and the people were so vibrant and active in India that it was not easy to influence the commission.

Dr Quraishi said every voter was important, and there were instances of walking an elephant three days to set up a polling station in a deep forest area for a lone voter, trekking

45 kilometres in snow in Ladakh, 16,000 feet above the sea level, to reach 37 voters, and using camels, boats, cycles, helicopters, and trains to transport polling personnel and materials.

The Election Commission tries to follow some rules for the convenience of the voters: No voter has to travel more than 2km, and no polling station should have more than 1,500 voters.

The former Indian CEC said the commission takes all possible steps to ensure inclusiveness while ramps are provided at polling stations for people with disabilities, Braille paper for the

blind, and companions to help physically-challenged persons.

Dr Quraishi had a good sense of humour too. During the presentation, he took pause to show some pictures of elephants, camels, and carts used, and snow-covered mountains visited during the polls. He described the national poll of India as the biggest event on Earth.

In the current national poll, the number of eligible voters reached the enormous figure of 814,500,000. Around 5 million people are employed to conduct the election. It is simply amazing how the largest event on Earth is conducted, and made almost flawless. “Our credibility is our pride,” Dr Quraishi said.

The conduct of the Indian national election should be an example to other countries, where frequent allegations of vote-rigging and use of muscle and money power are too common during elections. 

Top Brokers