There is no dearth of barriers to business, the business that is “of the people, by the people, and for the people.” The end of hartals and blockades is not the end of disturbances. Citizens who have to use roads, go to work, to school, to the hospital, or to shop, face this.
During the days of recent anti-election demonstrations, a merchandiser in Dhaka allegedly managed to escape detention in exchange of Tk1 lakh. He had to pay the money as he was told that he would be shown carrying explosives. The rate for a salesman at a retail shop in Kathalbagan for the same purpose at that time was Tk500.
In Cox’s Bazar of late, a group of youths who were on a recreational tour was handed over to human traffickers. According to media reports, the allegation went against the local police. At least 50% of criminal incidents are not reported to the police, due to fear of further harassment.
Is it really such a mess, or a deliberately created state of misgovernance? Otherwise, why don’t those who rule the country try to address the situation?
We equally blame the poor for setting up makeshift shops on footpaths, and the moneyed men for indiscriminately parking on busy roads. In both cases, some other people make money twice. They do so by allowing these informal businesses, and during the so-called drives against such activities.
In any case, the sufferers are the masses who have to come out of their houses. We have borrowed a system which has made the people subjects, not the sources of power. We named this nation the “people’s republic.” This redundant expression is like the “beheaded body of the headless man.”
Also, it comes as a fallacy: It is the people who matter the least in running the affairs of the state, including a day’s ballot.
In that republic, at least one citizen is falling victim to extra-judicial killings every day. A state minister acknowledged that there might be one or two mistakes in handling the detainees who were killed in crossfires. Would the minister accept this if that “only” victim happened to be he himself? Such conviction indicates how the power of the state dictates him to be blind about everything else.
The information minister stated that the government did not endorse the extra-judicial killings. Let us assume that he was true to his statement. In that case, there is a government above the government that he is a part of. If his government is not responsible for any killing without trial, why doesn’t it take a sympathetic view to the loss of lives, not to mention investigate the incidents?
The current regime is certainly not in a position to tame the long hands of the state from committing excesses. Powerful quarters are plagued by allegations of corrupt practices but they do not need to bother about public reactions to such misdeeds, since they, while in power, are beyond the reach of the commoners.
Hamza Alavi termed the post-colonial system in countries like ours “over-developed states.” We have inherited the colonial state but have not made its transformation to involve the people and serve them. The structure of the government and public service delivery have not changed much even after the end of colonial rule.
The only thing added to the system is the new group of local rulers who refrained from making, or failed to make it a “people’s republic” in its truest sense. They have rather developed newer strategies to divert demands from people and various citizen groups who talk about good governance and public welfare.
One such strategy we have witnessed recently is an unusual election that ensured the victory of the majority of legislators without a single vote being casted. Some of my respected seniors informally expressed their pious wishes that a guilty conscience might prompt the present rulers to do a better job of appeasing the people.
I humbly differ. Nothing better than depending on the coercive state apparatus can be expected of a government that neither represents the commoners’ sentiment, nor has the legitimate mandate of the majority.
The administration, especially the police, can claim the most credit for presenting a new lease of power to the present government.
The political leadership has failed to understand their weakness and bankruptcy in the process of governance. In the colonial state, we had alien rulers, whereas now we have rulers alienated from the people. Some people other than the politicians are more powerful “forever” while public representatives remain “guest birds.”
Under such a system, Sheikh Hasina, no matter how strong, good, and honest she is as prime minister, is not safe when she is a private citizen. Her predecessor, Khaleda Zia, surely is an example of how powerful people can be powerless when outside of the power structure.



