Arguments are now being made, carefully as well as callously, as to how and why the Awami League’s formation of the new government has been possible through an election that was boycotted by the BNP-led opposition. The BNP has been sidelined, at least for the time being, from the process of parliamentary politics. A naïve person may conclude that there are obvious winners and losers between the two sides, even though they did not face electoral competition on January 5.
Almost all eminent citizens, except pro-AL intellectuals, advocated that the general elections should be suspended to pave the way for the participation of the opposition parties. Such a position essentially favoured the BNP camp, which, however, announced demonstration programs to resist what has eventually turned into a somewhat farcical election. The majority of Bangladeshis had not been party to the elections, let alone this fake victory.
So what? Protagonists of the one-sided elections may argue that AL chief Sheikh Hasina has been re-elected as prime minister, keeping her control over the bureaucracy and law enforcement agencies. Of course, the will of the people can be ignored, if it is the choice of a regime, and it works until a revolutionary change takes place.
BNP chief Khaleda Zia’s followers could not overpower the administration and the police to stop the holding of elections despite enforcing hartals and blockades. Showing strength of what a former diplomat called “wild imagination,” Sheikh Hasina’s team managed to secure victory without any contest in 153 constituencies, and with the presence of (apparently) 40% of voters on a troubled election day.
Who cares if others believe the turnout was hardly 10% or less? After all, what matters most in politics is power, and the ends of all acts justify their means.
Yet, I still wonder who won and who lost. What happened to the masses who broadly remained spectators during the electoral process? What went wrong for the rival parties? From the controversial elections, Khaleda gained the stigmatisation of the AL, but Hasina consolidated all-important power. However, the former lost tactically, and the latter morally.
Commonly, they failed to win the hearts of the people, especially the rising middle class who clearly boycotted the ballot, but simultaneously refrained from joining the opposition movement.
They were not beneficiaries of either the AL or the BNP regime, nor were they party to these political games in any way. The citizens Hasina is supposed to govern have not given her the mandate to do so. The people Khaleda could have banked on as a support base have not found much appeal in the modes of demonstration that were seen, despite the need for a non-party government for holding free, fair, credible, and inclusive polls.
How will we then explain the loss of 22 lives in polls-related violence alone? I see three causes of deaths readiness among some opposition elements to end lives, the use of force by the government, and sabotage by unidentified quarters.
Whatever the reasons, many embraced for loss of life as a consequence. Nobody in the rival camps is being sympathetic towards the victims and their families, showing a cruel indifference.
So the people other than the ones involved with the AL and the BNP have preferred deliberate isolation from the current political process. The AL and the BNP count on their core support coming mainly from their beneficiaries to pursue their respective political goals. Fortunately or unfortunately, most people who have voted for the two parties since 1991 are not ready to take risks for the leaders.
If the number of beneficiaries of the two parties in the past two decades stands, let us suppose, at 3 million, the number of those who have tried to change their fates by their own enterprising efforts would be several times higher.
This silent majority, as Hasina is presumably assured, has not at least sided with the BNP. Hasina, as prime minister, is not accountable to them either. Khaleda’s success in seeing the majority’s absence in the January 5 election is yet to be transformed into a popular demonstration.
The enlightened and conscientious segments of society have been watching the situation evolving every day. Cynics may term this isolation as an opportunistic stance.
A meek civil society voice would allow bad governance from a regime suffering from a legitimacy crisis. How can we expect democracy to return from exile unless there is social activism for upholding civil rights?



