Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

The postman knocks twice

Update : 12 Jan 2014, 06:50 PM

A nation divided, says the Western press. Could it be true? The Economist thinks so. Prophetic words – “only one-third (of the Bangladeshis) want the two battling Begums barred from politics. Badly as they serve their country, it (the country) cannot seem to do without them,” (The Economist, December 21, 2013).

What’s going on? Certainly the cycle is all too familiar to the voters. A party wins the election with a bang. Lots of rejoicing takes place on getting rid of the old corrupt regime. A year into the new administration, corruption continues like inflation. Disillusion sets in, yearning for change starts anew, and the tormentors are kicked out after five.

The cycle goes on and on, and Bangladesh lives through the insanity of doing the same thing over and over again and expecting different results.

“Can this ever end?” asks one of my close friends, a true well-wisher. Good question. Ask this of the people of Bangladesh who are supposed to be politically savvy. History does not seem to bear that out, just as the opinion of The Economist. 

Perhaps a psychoanalysis of the Bangladeshi mind would explain this conundrum. We do not have undisputed national heroes like George Washington, Winston Churchill, or Nelson Mandela, nor do we truly want to embrace Gandhi or Sher-e-Bangla as our heroes (they are so pre-1971). So we heap our admiration on the two liberators of Bangladesh – Bangabandhu Sheikh Mujibur Rahman and General Ziaur Rahman.

Unfortunately, they exist at two opposite ends of public opinion. One cannot really like one without disliking the other. To a non-Bangladeshi, this is puzzling. After all, weren’t both of them responsible for the creation of Bangladesh? Didn’t both fulfill the mandate of delivering the oppressed nation from its tormenters? So true, yet so ignored. Half the country that supports one thinks that the other was a fiend.

In the case of Sheikh Mujib, he fell from esteem like Napoleon, but was not forgotten because he indeed was the father of the nation. In the case of Ziaur Rahman, his fall from grace was because some thought that he was the murderer of Sheikh Mujib, but they also thought of him as a deliverer of sorts from the ill-doings of the time. Rather paradoxical, because in the aftermath of BAKSAL, didn’t some want to (at least in their minds)assassinate the Sheikh, and didn’t the people rush to embrace the next dictator after the cruel demise of Ziaur Rahman?

Now it is really a moot issue whether Ziaur Rahman, who in turn got murdered by another force, was the cause of Sheikh Mujib’s death, or whether he was the victim. The point is, the country should make up its mind where to relegate these two pre-eminent figures of its history. One would think preferably to history alone.

Leadership is not genetically transferable, and dynastic succession spawns mediocrity. The mindless surrender of public ethos to the warring progeny of two good but dead men could only tear the country apart, as it is now. Isn’t it time for the country to give its demised heroes the eternal rest they deserve and bring a closure on the grief of their demise? And if it still cannot make up its mind on who to worship and who to reproach, it should simply acknowledge both to be their saviours, one way or the other, and move on.

Sadly, this has not happened nor seems to be happening. So the 5-year cycle of amore and disdain with the political successors of both leaders go on. This love-hate relationship has grown to a point where we eagerly await the change of the guards every five years, and the inevitable hegemony that comes with it in predictable cyclical manner like booms and busts. When the passion of “throwing the bums out” is riding high, nobody seems to remember the last time they felt the same.

I have often pondered on my friend’s question about where this would end. I couldn’t find the answer for so long because I thought alone. But now I see it clearly. Only when the people of Bangladesh together understand that enough is enough will it end for both the warring Begums. We got this chance twice. Will there be a third time?

Top Brokers