Is the AL about to make a historic mistake by forging ahead with the January 5 election?
Even many of those within the party privately concede that the elections will not have any legitimacy other than constitutional, and the party (to its credit) acknowledges openly that the results will not give it a mandate to rule for the next five years.
The argument is that the elections are now a constitutional necessity and that there is no alternative to going ahead with them if we wish to avoid a constitutional crisis.
Well, yes and no.
Whether the constitution allows for another 90 days after January 24 if the parliament is dissolved prior to then (which it clearly does, by my reading) or not, is a question of constitutional interpretation, I suppose.
But if the PM announced that she was invoking Article 123.3(b) of the constitution and taking another 90 days to hold elections, I am sure that she could pull it off.
The better argument against such a course of action is that it would solve nothing except to kick the can down the road a further three months, thus merely prolonging the current crisis, and that in the middle of April we would be back to square one, and with no parliament, to boot.
Be that as it may, there are cogent reasons for the AL to not go down that road, and instead to continue to seek compromise to try to bring the BNP into an election on mutually acceptable terms.
The principal one would be that the government elected on January 5 would suffer from a crisis of legitimacy from day one, in just the same way that the short-lived 6th parliament of 1996 did.
Right now, say what you will, the current parliament and cabinet have full and unquestionable constitutional and moral legitimacy. The parliament was democratically elected in December 2008 and the government was constitutionally constituted thereto.
Now, the 10th parliament will also be constitutional, there can be no question of that, but legitimacy does not follow mere constitutionality. What matters equally is whether it is seen to be legitimate by the people of Bangladesh and therefore by the administrative and law enforcement apparatus that exists to support it and without which it cannot function.
It was precisely this lack of legitimacy that brought the BNP-dominated 6th parliament to its knees and paved the way, ironically, for the 13th amendment and the caretaker government system.
Had the BNP agreed to the caretaker government prior to the farcical elections in February 1996, they would have had every chance of in fact prevailing in such elections, certainly a far better chance than in the ones that were subsequently held that June.
In the end, it was their machinations to try to prevent the caretaker government and their holding of a farcical election that destroyed the party’s credibility and sealed its fate in the subsequent elections held four months later.
The situation today is not quite analogous. The saving grace for the AL is its full acknowledgement that the upcoming elections will not give it a mandate to rule the country for the next five years. The election as constitutional necessity rather than popular mandate make it more acceptable and likely to be more accepted than its February 1996 counterpart.
Nevertheless, the danger remains that with the government’s legitimacy compromised in the public mind that it will find it hard to maintain control, and will, like the BNP in 1996, then be backed into a corner.
The AL is confident that it can not only maintain but enhance control post-elections, and for the sake of the nation, I hope they are right. The nation can ill afford another round of hartals and blockades, and the sooner we can return to some semblance of normalcy, the better.
However, I am not as confident that it will be quite as simple as the AL seems to think.
Of course, whether we have elections in January or three months down the line, the fundamental problem remains that the two sides are both determined to not compromise, and, to paraphrase the late, great Lou Reed: There’s no ground common enough for AL and BNP.
As long as that is the case, perhaps whether we hold elections now or later really doesn’t make all that much difference. I’ve said it before, and I’ll say it again: Without some kind of new compact between AL and BNP, elections will resolve nothing.
But neither side seems at all willing to back down or compromise. They are both playing for all the marbles. As ever, this is a high-stakes game of winner take all.
By sticking to the elections on January 5, the PM is saying that she’s seen enough. She is bringing the crisis to a head. She has pushed all of her chips into the middle of the table. She is all in.
It is possible that her hand is stronger than I am giving it credit for, in which case I guess that there is nothing to be gained by waiting any further, since any kind of mutually acceptable compromise between the two sides seems to be out of the question.
If there’s going to be a showdown, January 5 is as good a time for it as any. Assuming she’s holding a winning hand.



