The title of this article might upset supporters of BNP, a political party which held power through the democratic process for two full terms. But the continuous chilling remarks made by leaders of BNP and their cohort Jamaat-e-Islami force one to ponder the issue.
Early this year, Jamaat threatened to wage civil war while BNP leaders have encouraged replication of atrocities such as that in Fatikchhari against AL across the country.
One BNP senior leader, before a party rally in October, directed party leaders and activists to arm themselves with machetes, axes, and whatever weapon they can acquire to fight back if attacked.
At a rally in November, a Jamaat leader termed the Sitakunda mayhem as “just a sample” and threatened that “the whole country would turn into Sitakundu.” Another Jamaat leader at the same rally warned of setting ablaze the entire 56,000 square miles of the country.
The latest came through another senior BNP leader’s apparent justification of the recent brutality carried out against ordinary people by killing them indiscriminately and burning passengers to death and sabotaging train movement by dismantling fish plates on rail tracks during past weeks of BNP-Jamaat alliance’s hartals and blockades.
In response to people’s fear, the senior leader justified these actions by saying: “Does this not happen when there is a war? Don’t you see the Western powers are killing so many innocent civilians in the war in Afghanistan? Don’t you see children getting killed? Don’t you see women getting killed?”
Based on this latest stance, one can thus conclude that BNP-Jamaat actually see themselves as waging an undeclared war – which BNP’s political ally Jamaat already threatened at the beginning of the year.
Though the killing spree of the innocent ordinary people is happening during the 18-party alliance’s blockades or hartals, BNP-Jamaat blames the government and disclaims their responsibility for these atrocities. But their speeches throughout the year stand contrary to their words.
Rather, the BNP acting secretary general in November seemingly acknowledged that opposition leaders and activists were engaged in street violence during their anti-government agitation. In a program of their student wing, the BNP leader said that opposition activists have to do much more than just vandalise one or two vehicles on the street to have the BNP-led alliance’s demands met.
In October, a renowned columnist and active sympathiser of BNP-Jamaat alliance and fundamentalist Hefazat-e-Islam, said on a talk show program that journalists “deserved” to be bombed as he thinks the media of today ignored the opposition’s issues: “Such ignorance will eventually lead to bombings. The bombings in recent times have been very little, I think it should have been more.”
When the latest BNP statement defending the recent violence by comparing it to collateral damage during war became an issue of debate, BNP supporters justified this statement, giving even more frightening comparisons.
A professor of Dhaka University, on a talk show program not only defended the statement, but added examples of the activities of India’s Maoist terror groups and also an Indian separatist group ULFA (United Liberation Front of Assam). Terror acts in Afghanistan and Pakistan were also brought into consideration during the discussion on the program, where the professor tried to justify the opposition’s ongoing violence.
We have witnessed political movement and violence in the country during the last four decades. We saw processions, rallies of thousands of people of the both ruling AL and BNP during the 9-year long rule of military dictator HM Ershad and even afterwards when the two major parties were in power one after another. We witnessed party leaders of different levels in the street along with their regular activists and supporters join the program.
Even those people who did not belong to any party but supported the cause of the movement also came to the street to extend their solidarity to the movement. We saw brutality of the law enforcers on the protestors during all regimes in the past. We witnessed violent clashes between protestors and police, even protestors throwing crude bombs and cocktails during those clashes. But those were absolutely limited to the political protestors and police or among the rival political groups.
Killing ordinary people was never the target of the protestors.
Jamaat and their student wing Islami Chhatra Shibir activists have waged a planned war on police since last year. Now many common people are being killed every day. The opposition deny responsibility on the one hand, while on the other hand defend these crimes in a way, as if they are admitting their responsibility for these crimes.
What is most alarming is that the BNP and Jamaat are not only conducting these crimes as part of a political and democratic movement, but they and their supporters do not hesitate to cite the example of the war-like situation in Afghanistan, Pakistan, and in some parts of India.
Are they really advancing towards taking insurgency groups as their model? Are they imposing war against the people in the name of democratic political movement to meet their demands?
If so, isn’t there any reason to ponder the question in the title?



