Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

What do the Bangladeshi people want?

Update : 05 Dec 2013, 06:41 PM

Let’s drop the charade. The country is in no position to go to the polls in less than a month’s time. Enough of the closed door meetings and cloak and dagger negotiations between the great and the good and our foreign friends to try to bring the AL and the BNP together and to rush through an election by January 5.

The simple truth is that the AL and BNP were never going to compromise on a formula acceptable to both sides, and the sooner we stop pretending that this was ever on the cards, the better. If there had been any intention on either side to find common ground, it could have been found, but there was none, and this has been apparent for months.

On this particular issue there is enough blame to go around. The AL should never have amended the constitution to end the caretaker government system, in the teeth of public opinion, giving the BNP a gilt-edged excuse to boycott the elections.

By the same token, it is pretty clear that the BNP had no desire to find any kind of mutually acceptable compromise short of the caretaker government, even though there were many workable possibilities that could have been arrived at through good faith negotiation.

In fact, even had the caretaker government system never been scrapped, I am pretty sure that we would right now be embroiled in a reprise of 2006 but this time with the BNP complaining about Justice Khairul Haque as chief adviser.

The bottom line is that the compact of even minimal cooperation between the two sides that had existed since 1991 has broken down completely.  The AL and the BNP simply cannot co-exist anymore in any meaningful way and this is a new reality that we have yet to adjust to.

We now have a situation where the law enforcement authorities are conducting pre-dawn raids on safe houses to haul BNP leaders into custody and the BNP has been reduced to issuing video statements from undisclosed locations, al-Qaeda style.

Meanwhile all hell is breaking loose. Buses are being torched, railway lines cut, and inter-city transport has been brought to a virtual standstill. The death toll for the year is over 700, with almost 20,000 injured, and the majority of these have been innocent civilians and not political activists (not that killing or maiming political activists is acceptable, either).

Under what understanding of the process does the preceding suggest that we are in any way prepared for an election or that if we were able to hold one, that it would be of any value or do anything to change the fundamental problems on the ground.

The issue is not whether our octogenarian ex-dictator and his party participates in the election or not. How can the legitimacy or acceptability of the elections depend on something so capricious as his calculation as to which way the political wind is blowing and who will cut him the better deal?

Please. Don’t insult the Bangladeshi people. In fact, in this entire sorry saga, no one has thought to ask the people what it is that we might want. The decisions as to the make-up of the interim government and the modalities of the election and whether they would be acceptable or not have been made entirely without recourse to the people on whose behalf this whole rigmarole is ostensibly being conducted – we, the people.

This shouldn’t be about what the BNP wants or what the AL is willing to concede to them. This shouldn’t be about whether the JP is taking part in the elections or not. The question everyone should be asking is: What do the Bangladeshi people want?

At no point has that question been the guiding concern of the political process this past year, and that has been the problem. It is not only that the main political parties can no longer co-exist, it is that neither of them now even makes a pretence of serving the public interest.

All elections are not short-hand for the will of the people, and forcing through elections as the country burns should not be confused with asking the people what they want. The people want a meaningful choice.  The question is whether the January 5 elections can deliver this. To ask the question is to answer it.

The time has come to ask the Bangladeshi people what they want. This single, simple, elegant question should be at the heart of any democratic process, but when was the last time it was asked by either the party that took a decision that was opposed by up to 90% of the population or by the party that has burned the country to the ground in response?

Top Brokers