Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Washington pays attention

Update : 23 Nov 2013, 07:28 PM

On the wintry November 20 afternoon in Washington, DC, Bangladesh received major attention in the halls of power. Inside a white marble, four-story building next to the US Capitol Building, the House Subcommittee on Asia and the Pacific held a congressional hearing titled: “Bangladesh in Turmoil: A Nation on the Brink?”

As the South Asian media filled the press table and the Bangladesh ambassador to the US viewed from a front-row seat, the Awami League government received intense scrutiny from the parliamentary body of the world’s superpower. Congress members and witnesses depicted an abysmal scenario where Bangladesh could head toward total political breakdown.

Subcommittee Chairman Steve Chabot stated: “The country is in a state of political turmoil.  Political operatives utilise strikes, riots, and blockades to destabilise the country.” The congressman went to Bangladesh on a two-day visit earlier this month and assessed that the violence could lead to broader security risks for the region. 

He observed that both the prime minister and opposition leader were adamant in their positions, with Sheikh Hasina insisting that provisions are in place for a fair election. He also criticised the International Crimes Tribunal for not meeting international standards, and concluded: “Bangladesh has much going for it and much standing in the way of its continuing progress.”

Representative Tulsi Gabbard conveyed her concerns regarding attacks on the Hindu community and worker safety violations. She reiterated the US mantra to create an environment for free, fair, and credible elections, stating: “The US continues to be concerned about the political deadlock.”

Congressman Brad Sherman mentioned religious-minority abuses and the harassment of Professor Yunus. In a nutshell, all three witnesses squarely blamed the prime minister’s cancellation of the interim caretaker government as the critical issue igniting the turbulence. 

Professor Ali Riaz, a public policy scholar at the think-tank Woodrow Wilson Center, stated that it was unlikely for a routine election to take place as the opposition may boycott the election, or the entire election may be deferred. He recommended that the US emphasise quality of democracy by prescribing concrete steps to be followed by political parties, with rewards such as tariff removal. 

Additionally, he advised that the US should assist building a strong Election Commission, encourage containment of religious extremism, and neither franchise its responsibilities or exclude India from its strategies. He also suggested accommodating the opposition’s demand to hold the election without the prime minister as head of government.

Major General Muniruzzaman (retired), head of Bangladesh Institute of Peace and Security Studies, noted that the incumbent government had the capacity to manipulate elections and in the absence of a strong Election Commission, a fair election could only be conducted by a caretaker government. He also warned that the rising tendency of Islamic militants and the current state of political turbulence by the government would lead to instability. 

Moreover, he emphasised the need to change the political culture, freeing the judiciary branch from the executive, making the anticorruption and election commissions more accountable, and forming national policies, not just personal policies.  He also stressed that although the military does not have the appetite for a government takeover, it remains the only credible force in the nation and increased political violence may suck the military into the crisis. 

In his written testimony, the major general stated: “There is likely to be a military-backed interim civilian government to hold a fair election and transfer power to the elected. Any prolonged stay of such government beyond six to eight months would be harmful to Bangladesh.”

John Sifton from Human Rights Watch probably provided the most damning indictment. He illustrated a dire political scenario where the government exhibits illegal, excessive force against opponents and by HRW estimates, 150 protesters have been killed and 2,000 injured by security forces since February this year.

He mentioned visiting human rights group Odhikar in Dhaka and noticing plainclothes police keeping watch by the entrance, stating that “the overt surveillance is pathetic and thuggish.” He encouraged Congress to remind the Bangladesh government that its most important needs, such as gaining low tariffs and continuing peacekeeping missions, will be placed at risk in case of a political implosion.

Foreign Affairs Committee Chairman Ed Royce joined at the end of the hearing, conveying that Islamist radicalism is the wider problem. The congressman compared Bangladesh to Pakistan in fermenting Islamist terror via Deobandi madrasa education.

He asserted that Hindus have fled to India and religious-minority communities have been targeted by a small, radicalised group sowing terror, with the police turning a blind eye. The government must close down radicalised Deobandi schools, or the state will collapse. 

Upon Assistant Secretary of State Nisha Biswal’s November 17 visit with Khaleda Zia, BNP Vice Chairman Shamsher Chowdhury noted that the assistant secretary praised the opposition leader’s recent speech at a press conference, terming it path-showing with an outline to strengthen democracy. 

Out of 14 subcommittee members, only two representatives held the Bangladesh hearing. There was no possible debate among the members on whether Bangladesh was on the brink. Although renowned experts in their fields, the selected witnesses basically corroborated how much turmoil the nation is undergoing; there was not one witness to refute the allegations or defend the government’s approach. 

Chairman Royce briefly stepped in to offer an alarmist statement toward the end. Despite the Awami League government cracking down on Islamist terrorism, why compare Bangladesh to Pakistan, a nation with pervasive US intervention due to the global threat of terrorism?  Furthermore, upon concluding his Bangladesh trip, why did Congressman Chabot label the opposition leader as: “probably soon-to-be again Prime Minister Khaleda Zia?” 

Finally, America’s most prominent newspaper presents a highly critical editorial on the Awami League’s governance.  The New York Times’ November 20 edition reports that this year, hundreds have died in political battles, top opposition leaders have been arrested, and the court has delivered guilty verdicts that flout due process standards. The editorial notes: “Responsibility for this crisis sits squarely with Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina. If violations of rights continue, Bangladesh could face pressure, including perhaps sanctions, from the international community.”

As the political violence in this South Asian nation reaches a crescendo, what is the world’s superpower planning for this country that is tied to it with multibillion-dollar trade and global security? In 2007, the knights were aligned by the international community to remove the queen’s handpicked bishop. One hopes that this time around, US engagement with Bangladesh actually benefits the common citizens, and not just the chess masters.

Top Brokers