Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Diagnosis of a share-taker government

Update : 21 Nov 2013, 07:12 PM

The parliament may be the constitutional platform for democratic debate, but for the netizens of Bangladesh (citizens using internet), Facebook is where their thoughts are formulated, expressed and debated.

It is where lively arguments happen on private walls and statuses without moderation and (almost) no fear of backlash. It has become something strikingly close to a people’s parliament. And it is on Facebook that the term “share-taker government” was coined by a free-thinking imaginative friend. Where else?

The term undoubtedly pokes fun at the allegedly “all-party” government that now exists in Bangladesh. Supposedly having roots in the opposition’s demand for a caretaker government, the current cabinet comprises of ministers from a few more parties in parliament in what can be described as a power sharing arrangement. But the question is, is this the “small” cabinet promised by the prime minister, free of “unelected” forces, having only the purpose of overseeing an election?

At the time of writing this article, it is still not clear whether the ministers who submitted their resignation letters to the prime minister on November 10 are still in office. If they are, the size of the cabinet stands at 67, if they are not, the cabinet is still a substantial 21 even without the participation of BNP, the second biggest party in parliament.

If compared to the usual election-time caretaker government comprising of 10 advisers, this cabinet is already more than twice as big, with the potential to be thrice as big in the unlikely situation that BNP will join. The government is certainly not “small” in size.

But is it small in significance? A quick look at the party portfolios of the new ministers will show that it is not. The two new Awami League entrants are both members of the party’s presidium, the new Jatiya Party ministers include its secretary-general and two presidium members and the Worker’s Party representative in the cabinet is the party’s chairman himself!

Not only do these ministers hold important posts in the party, they will presumably also be the most involved in the election-time strategy and management of their respective parties. While the obvious red-flag that springs up is that the danger arises of these ministers having an interest in influencing the election process, one thing is quite clear – this government is not “small”, neither in size nor in the power and influence it holds.

Nevertheless, the biggest argument forwarded by the prime minister and her party colleagues in favour of rejecting BNP’s demand for a neutral and non-party government, has been the idea that unelected people must not hold state power.

Yet, three unelected ministers continue to hold important posts in the cabinet, including the vital post of minister for law, justice and parliamentary affairs, and seven unelected advisers given the status of ministers, continue to advise the prime minister without any accountability in parliament or elsewhere. 

Ironically, while the rest of the “elected” cabinet was asked to hand in their resignations, the “unelected” advisers sat safely and soundly holding on to their ministerial status.

Most shocking, however, is the composition of the “new” recruits. The recent entrants, who supposedly are the flag-bearers of the small “elected” cabinet includes the wife of a business tycoon – a member of parliament certainly, but from the quota of selected female MPs.

Neither was she elected to the parliament, nor does she have any past experience of representing the people. Another new member, a Jatiya Party presidium member, and not an MP, has been added to the unaccountable post of an adviser, holding ministerial power and responsibility.

The current cabinet is certainly not a reflection of a “small” one or one which is “elected” or entirely democratic as had been promised by the prime minister. But is it substantially different from the usual government for it to be called an election-time government that is the solution to the current political stalemate? The answer is an unfortunate no.

With the prime minister remaining at the helm of the government, most of the government power remains centralised in the untouched PMO. The important ministries of Defence, Foreign, Home and Law are tipped to remain unchanged as well.

In this backdrop, the cabinet entries look less like a new government and more like a cabinet reshuffle, which is unlikely to convince the opposition or the public that this is an election-time government.

Nevertheless, while the characteristics of a government tasked with overseeing a free and fair election process is missing from the present format, it is not a format that needs to be binned necessarily.

There is scope for change and improvement; and a more open, sincere and inclusive approach with the goal of an all-party election in mind can put an end to the painful and costly stalemate that exists in the country right now.

Top Brokers